Agendabundel
Tekst van het document
9RRUKHWRSEXONHQVDPHQYRHJHQYDQSDUWLMHQDIYDOVWRIIHQZRUGHQGHXLWJDQJVSXQWHQPHW EHWUHNNLQJWRWKHWPHQJHQ]RDOVRSJHQRPHQLQSDUDJUDDIYDQKHW/$3LQDFKW JHQRPHQ'LWKRXGWLQGDWELMKHWRSEXONHQVDPHQYRHJHQYDQGHSDUWLMHQDIYDOVWRIIHQ UHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQZRUGWPHWGHYROJHQGHDVSHFWHQ KHWPHQJHQYDQDIYDOVWRIIHQPDJJHHQQDGHOLJHFRQVHTXHQWLHVKHEEHQYRRUKHW PLOLHXHQGHYRONVJH]RQGKHLG]RZHOLQDOJHPHQH]LQDOVRSLQULFKWLQJVQLYHDX HUPRHWZRUGHQYRRUNRPHQGDWPHQJHQHUWRHOHLGWGDWppQYDQGHWHPHQJHQ DIYDOVWRIIHQQLHWFRQIRUPGHPLQLPXPVWDQGDDUGYRRUGLHDIYDOVWURRPZRUGW YHUZHUNW HUPRHWZRUGHQYRRUNRPHQGDWKHWPHQJHQYDQDIYDOVWRIIHQOHLGWWRWEHODVWLQJ YDQKHWPLOLHXGRRUGLIIXVHYHUVSUHLGLQJYDQVSHFLILHNHPLOLHXJHYDDUOLMNHVWRIIHQ ZDDUYRRURSJURQGYDQLQWHUQDWLRQDOHUHJHOJHYLQJ YHUJDDQGH EHSHUNLQJHQ JHOGHQ GHPHQJKDQGHOLQJWHQDDQ]LHQYDQDIYDOVWRIIHQGLHQWXLWJHYRHUGWHZRUGHQ YROJHQVGHEHVWEHVFKLNEDUHWHFKQLHNHQZDDUELMGHDDQGDFKWXLWGLHQWWHJDDQ QDDUGHLQYORHGRSGHHPLVVLHVYDQXLWGHLQULFKWLQJ HUPRHWYRRUNRPHQZRUGHQGDWKHWPHQJHQYDQDIYDOVWRIIHQDQGHUVRRUWLJH ULVLFR¶VPHW]LFKPHHEUHQJWYRRUGHPHQVHQ]LMQRPJHYLQJZDDUELMGHQDGUXNOLJW RSVSHFLILHNHYHLOLJKHLGHQDUERJHUHODWHHUGH]DNHQ 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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³0LOLHXK\JLsQLVFKHNHXULQJYDQLQGLYLGXHOHSDUWLMHQJURQGLQ
KHWNDGHUYDQKHW%HVOXLWERGHPNZDOLWHLW´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³PHQJHQHQKRPRJHQLVHUHQ´+HW³HLQGSURGXFW´ZRUGW YHUYROJHQVEXLWHQGHLQULFKWLQJQXWWLJWRHJHSDVWRIYHUZHUNWGRRUHHQYHUJXQQLQJKRXGHUPHW HHQWRHUHLNHQGHYHUJXQQLQJ 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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
YHUNOHLQGPHWDOVGRHOKHWKRXWDFKWLJJURHQDIYDOJHVFKLNWWHPDNHQYRRUQXWWLJHWRHSDVVLQJ LQGHYRUPYDQPDWHULDDOKHUJHEUXLN$IKDQNHOLMNYDQGHPDUNWVLWXDWLHNDQKHWKRXWDFKWLJH JURHQDIYDOEHZHUNWZRUGHQWRWELRPDVVDELRILOWHUPDWHULDDOVORRWGHPSLQJVPDWHULDDO VWUXFWXXUPDWHULDDOYRRUFRPSRVWHULQJPDWHULDDOYRRUODQGVFKDSSHOLMNHGRHOHLQGHQHG+HW YHUNOHLQHQHQVFKHLGHQYLQGWSODDWVPHWHHQPRELHOHLQVWDOODWLHGLHWXVVHQGHNHHUZDQGHQ]DO ZRUGHQRSJHVWHOGWHQ]XLGZHVWHQYDQGH]RXWORRGV 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
$HQ%KRXWNXQQHQELQQHQGHLQULFKWLQJRSHHQYHUJHOLMNEDUHZLM]HZRUGHQEHZHUNWWRW VQLSSHUDFKWLJPDWHULDDO$KRXWNDQQDEHZHUNLQJZRUGHQDIJH]HWDOVJURQGVWRIYRRUGH VSDDQSODDWLQGXVWULHRIDOVELRPDVVD EUDQGVWRI %KRXWZRUGWQDEHZHUNLQJDIJHYRHUGQDDU HHQJHsLJHQGYHUJXQQLQJKRXGHUYRRUYHUYROJYHUZHUNLQJYRRUQXWWLJHWRHSDVVLQJ+HW YHUNOHLQHQHQVFKHLGHQYLQGWSODDWVPHWHHQPRELHOHLQVWDOODWLHGLHWXVVHQGHNHHUZDQGHQ]DO ZRUGHQRSJHVWHOGWHQ]XLGZHVWHQYDQGH]RXWORRGV E KHWEUHNHQYDQSXLQ 'HDDQJHYRHUGHSDUWLMHQVWHHQDFKWLJHPDWHULDOHQZRUGHQWLMGHOLMNORVRSKHWEXLWHQWHUUHLQ JHVWRUWRILQEXONRSJHVODJHQ+HWVWHHQDFKWLJPDWHULDDOZRUGWPLGGHOVHHQVKRYHORINUDDQLQ HHQPRELHOHEUHNHULQVWDOODWLHLQJHYRHUGDOZDDUKHWFRQIRUPGH%5/ FHUWLILFHULQJ JHEURNHQZRUGWWRW PHQJ JUDQXODDW1DKHWEUHNHQZRUGWKHWPDWHULDDODIJHYRHUGGRRU PLGGHOYDQHHQWUDQVSRUWEDQGZDDUKHW]RZHOPDFKLQDDODOVKDQGPDWLJRQWGDDQNDQZRUGHQ YDQYHURQWUHLQLJHQ EYPHWDOHQQLHWVWHHQDFKWLJERXZHQVORRSDIYDO +HWJHEURNHQ PDWHULDDOZRUGWQRJPDDOVJH]HHIGZDDUELMGH]HHIRYHUORRSJHUHWRXUQHHUGZRUGWQDDUGH PRELHOH EUHNHU+HWDIJH]HHIGHJHEURNHQPDWHULDDOZRUGWPLGGHOVHHQWUDQVSRUWEDQGRS HHQKRRSJHVWRUW(HQVKRYHOWUDQVSRUWHHUWKHWPDWHULDDOYHUYROJHQVQDDUGHGHILQLWLHYH
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
JHORVWJHODGHQPLGGHOVHHQVKRYHOKHIWUXFN =RXWRSVODJ ,QGH]RXWORRGVZRUGWYRRUDO]RXWFTSHNHORSJHVODJHQ*H]LHQGHPRJHOLMNKHLGWRWXLWORJLQJ LVKHWEHWUHIIHQGHPDWHULDDOLQSDQGLJRSJHVODJHQRSHHQYORHLVWRINHUHQGHYORHUHQWHJHQ
6WFUWYDQIHEUXDUL
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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±ULVLFR¶V'HSURHIQHPLQJHQKHEEHQWHDOOHQWLMGHHHQ WLMGHOLMNNDUDNWHU
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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
YRRUKHHQ1H5 'HLQGH LQULFKWLQJDDQZH]LJHVWXLIJHYRHOLJH DIYDO VWRIIHQ]LMQLQKRRIGOLMQHQJURQG]DQGJURHQDIYDO JHEURNHQSXLQ VWURRL ]RXW(HQGHHOKLHUYDQLVLQHUW(HQDQGHUGHHOLVQLHWLQHUWRI XLWORRJEDDU ELMYRRUEHHOGYHUYXLOGHJURQGHQVWURRL]RXW 'LWODDWVWHEHWHNHQWGDWRSGH LQULFKWLQJQDDVWKHW$FWLYLWHLWHQEHVOXLWRRNGHKDQGOHLGLQJOXFKWHPLVVLHVELMEHGULMYHQYDQ PDDUWYDQWRHSDVVLQJLV (HUGHULVDOYDVWJHVWHOGGDWGH5,(YDQWRHSDVVLQJLVHQVSUDNHLVYDQHHQ,33&LQVWDOODWLH 'DDUPHHLVYHUYROJHQVRRNGH³%5()RSHQRYHUVODJ´HQGH´%5()$IYDOEHKDQGHOLQJ´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
JHWURIIHQFTLQDFKWJHQRPHQWHZRUGHQ ,QGHLQELMODJH³2YHU]LFKW DIYDO VWRIIHQKXOSHQWRHVODJVWRIIHQHQSURGXFWHQ´ELMGH]H DDQYUDDJLVGHVWXLINODVVHSHU DIYDO VWRIYHUPHOG 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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± KHW$PVWHUGDP5LMQNDQDDO±DDQZH]LJLV DIVWDQGFDPHWHU 2YHULJHJHYRHOLJH REMHFWHQ]LMQRSHHQJURWHUHDIVWDQGGDQPHWHUYDQGHLQULFKWLQJYHUZLMGHUG +HWYUDFKWYHUNHHURSKHWWHUUHLQULMGWRYHUHHQHJDOHYHUKDUGLQJZDDUELMPHWHHQODJH VQHOKHLGZRUGWJHUHGHQZDDUGRRUWULOOLQJHQYHURRU]DDNWGRRUKHWULMGHQWRWHHQPLQLPXP ZRUGHQEHSHUNW'HVQHOKHLGYDQGHYUDFKWZDJHQVRSKHWLQULFKWLQJVWHUUHLQLVEHSHUNWWRW FLUFDNPX'DDUQDDVWZRUGWKHWYUDFKWYHUNHHUQLHWJHKLQGHUGGRRUHQLJHYRUPYDQ REVWDNHOV*H]LHQKHWIHLWGDWYUDFKWZDJHQVQLHWODQJVZRQLQJHQ]XOOHQULMGHQNDQYHUGHU
ZRUGHQJHVWHOGGDWRRNWHQJHYROJHYDQPRELHOHEURQQHQJHHQWULOOLQJVKLQGHU]DORSWUHGHQ OLFKWKLQGHU +HWWHUUHLQLV¶VDYRQGHQ¶VQDFKWVEHSHUNWYHUOLFKWYHUJHOLMNEDDUPHWGHKXLGLJHVLWXDWLH $OOHHQLQKHWJHYDOYDQZHUN]DDPKHGHQZRUGWHUJHULFKWYHUOLFKW'LWJHOGWPHWQDPHYRRUGH ZHUN]DDPKHGHQDDQGHODDGHQORVNDGH,QGLHQHUJHHQVFKHSHQZRUGHQEHODGHQRIJHORVW LVGHYHUOLFKWLQJXLWJHVFKDNHOG$OOHHQELMKHWGDDGZHUNHOLMNEHODGHQRIORVVHQYHQDDQVFKLS LVYHUOLFKWLQJDDQZH]LJ'H]HYHUOLFKWLQJLV]RGDQLJDIJHVWHOGGDWGLUHFWHOLFKWLQYDOELM ZRQLQJHQLQDDQGHRYHU]LMGHZRUGWYRRUNRPHQ 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
ERGHPHQJURQGZDWHU ERGHPNZDOLWHLW %LQQHQGHLQULFKWLQJLVGHHOVVSUDNHYDQ SRWHQWLHHO ERGHPEHGUHLJHQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQ,QKHW $FWLYLWHLWHQEHVOXLWRQGHUGHZHUNLQJVVIHHUEHSDOLQJDUWDRYHUERGHPVWDDWHHQ XLW]RQGHULQJVEHSDOLQJPEWDUWOLGYRRULQULFKWLQJHQZDDUWRHHHQ,33&LQVWDOODWLH EHKRRUW9ROJHQVGH5LFKWOLMQ,QGXVWULsOH(PLVVLHVPRHWHHQERGHPRQGHU]RHNVUDSSRUW ZRUGHQRYHUOHJGYRRUGHVWDUWYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQ'DDURPLVLQGHPLQLVWHULsOHUHJHOLQJ RPJHYLQJVZHW 0RUDUWOLG HHQEHSDOLQJRSJHQRPHQGDWKHWUDSSRUW RQGHU]RHN FRQIRUP%HVOXLWERGHPNZDOLWHLWRIZHORSEDVLVYDQ1(1 RYHUGHERGHPNZDOLWHLWELMGH DDQYUDDJRPHHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJPRHWZRUGHQLQJHGLHQG (HQH[HPSODDUYDQGHYROJHQGHUDSSRUWDJHVEHKRUHQGHELMKHWUHFHQWXLWJHYRHUGH ERGHPRQGHU]RHN]LMQDOVELMODJH%RGHPRQGHU]RHNVUDSSRUWWRHJHYRHJGWHZHWHQ - QXOVLWXDWLHERGHPRQGHU]RHN6RSKLDODDQSURMHFWQXPPHU8WUHFKW /DJHZHLGHPDDUW - QXOVLWXDWLHERGHPRQGHU]RHN6RSKLDODDQSURMHFWQXPPHU$8WUHFKW /DJHZHLGHDSULO 9RRUGHFRQFOXVLHVYHUZLM]HQZLMQDDUGHLQKRXGYDQGHUDSSRUWDJHV'HEHWUHIIHQGH UDSSRUWDJHVGLHQHQWHUYDVWVWHOOLQJYDQGHQXOVLWXDWLH ERGHPEHVFKHUPLQJ 'HGRRU'H7ULS%9DDQJHYUDDJGHDFWLYLWHLWHQ]LMQJHWRHWVWDDQGH1HGHUODQGVH5LFKWOLMQ
%RGHPEHVFKHUPLQJEHGULMIVPDWLJHDFWLYLWHLWHQRIWHZHOGH15%9RRUGHRQGHUKDYLJH LQULFKWLQJLVHHQERGHPULVLFRDQDO\VH 15%DQDO\VH RSJHVWHOGGLHVHSDUDDWDOVELMODJH ELMGHDDQYUDDJLVJHYRHJG ,QGH15%DQDO\VH]LMQDDQGHKDQGYDQERGHPULVLFRFKHFNOLVWXLWGH15%HHQDDQWDO WRHWVLQJVVFKHPD¶VRSJHVWHOGZDDULQYRRUDOOHERGHPEHODVWHQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQGLHELQQHQGH LQULFKWLQJXLWJHYRHUGZRUGHQGHYHUHLVWHERGHPEHVFKHUPHQGHYRRU]LHQLQJHQHQRI PDDWUHJHOHQEHSDDOG]LMQWHQHLQGHHHQYHUZDDUORRVEDDUERGHPULVLFRWHEHKDOHQ 8LWGH15%DQDO\VHEOLMNWGDWPHWGHFRPELQDWLHVYDQYRRU]LHQLQJHQHQPDDWUHJHOHQYRRU DOOHDFWLYLWHLWHQHHQYHUZDDUORRVEDDUERGHPULVLFREHKDDOGZRUGWFRQIRUPGH15% 'DDUGHJHWURIIHQPDDWUHJHOHQFTYRRU]LHQLQJHQYRRUWNRPHQXLWGH15%YROGRHWGH LQULFKWLQJDDQGH%HVW%HVFKLNEDUH7HFKQLHN %%7 DIYDOZDWHU 'HEHGULMIVYRHULQJYDQ'H7ULS%9LVHURSJHULFKWKHWZDWHUYHUEUXLN]REHSHUNWPRJHOLMNWH KRXGHQHQKHWRQWVWDDQYDQDIYDOZDWHUHQYHURQWUHLQLJLQJGDDUYDQ]RYHHOPRJHOLMNWHUXJWH EUHQJHQ,QGH%5()$IYDOEHKDQGHOLQJZRUGHQHHQDDQWDO%%7¶VJHQRHPGRSKHWJHELHG YDQZDWHUYHUEUXLN %$7HHQ 'DDUQDDVWLVGHEHGULMIVYRHULQJYDQ'H7ULS%9PHGHJHOHWRSGHLQDUWLNHOOLGVXEG YDQKHW$FWLYLWHLWHQEHVOXLWQHHUJHOHJGH]RUJSOLFKW]RGDQLJLQJHULFKWGDWHU]RYHHOPRJHOLMN
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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
KHWDDQWDOGDJHQQHHUVODJSHUMDDUZRUGWPSHUHWPDDOJHORRVGHQUHNHQLQJKRXGHQGH PHW]ZDUHQHHUVODJNDQGHPD[LPDOHQHHUVODJPXXUEHGUDJHQ DIYDOVWRIIHQ 'HYULMNRPHQGHDIYDOVWRIIHQHQUHVLGXHQGLHELQQHQGHLQULFKWLQJRQWVWDDQDOVJHYROJYDQKHW XLWYRHUHQYDQGHDDQJHYUDDJGHDFWLYLWHLWHQ]LMQJHWRHWVWDDQGHLQGH%5() $IYDOEHKDQGHOLQJJHQRHPGH%%7¶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
ELMEHKRUHQGHSURGXFWLQIRUPDWLHEODGHQ0RFKWHURQYHUKRRSWWRFKKLQGHUHQRIRYHUODVWYDQ RQJHGLHUWHRSWUHGHQGDQ]DOKLHUYRRUHHQJHVSHFLDOLVHHUGRQJHGLHUWHEHVWULMGLQJVEHGULMI LQJHKXXUGZRUGHQ
KWWSZZZFRPSHQGLXPYRRUGHOHHIRPJHYLQJQOLQGLFDWRUHQQO0HWHRURORJLVFKHJHJHYHQVLQ 1HGHUODQGKWPO"L KWWSVZZZNQPLQONHQQLVHQGDWDFHQWUXPXLWOHJ]ZDUHQHHUVODJRSSHUYODNWHP PPXXU
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
H[WHUQHYHLOLJKHLG ,QGLWKRRIGVWXNZRUGWEHRRUGHHOGZHONHYDQGHKLHUQDJHQRHPGHWRHWVLQJVNDGHUVDDQZHW HQUHJHOJHYLQJYDQWRHSDVVLQJ]LMQRSGHDFWLYLWHLWHQGLHGRRU'H7ULS%9EHRRJG]LMQ$OV WRHWVLQJVNDGHUVZRUGHQDDQJHPHUNW - %HVOXLW5LVLFR V=ZDUH2QJHYDOOHQ %5=2 - %HVOXLWH[WHUQHYHLOLJKHLGLQULFKWLQJHQ %HYL - 3XEOLFDWLHUHHNV*HYDDUOLMNH6WRIIHQ 3*6
(QNHOH DIYDO VWRIIHQ]LMQRSJHQRPHQLQELMODJH,YDQKHW%5=2PDDUGHPD[LPDOH KRHYHHOKHGHQDDQVWRIIHQGLHELM'H7ULS%9DDQZH]LJNXQQHQ]LMQOLJJHQEHGXLGHQGODJHU GDQGHGUHPSHOZDDUGHQGLHYROJHQVKHW%5=2YDQWRHSDVVLQJ]LMQ'HUKDOYHLVKHW%5=2 QLHWYDQWRHSDVVLQJLQJHYDOYDQGHLQULFKWLQJYDQ'H7ULS%9 %LQQHQGHLQULFKWLQJJHHQDFWLYLWHLWHQSODDWVGLHH[SOLFLHWYDOOHQRQGHUGHFDWHJRULHsQYDQ LQULFKWLQJHQ]RDOVRSJHQRPHQLQKHW%HYLRIKHWELMEHKRUHQGH5HYL 5HJHOLQJH[WHUQH YHLOLJKHLGLQULFKWLQJHQ 'H3XEOLFDWLHUHHNV*HYDDUOLMNH6WRIIHQ 3*6 EHYDWULFKWOLMQHQPHWEHWUHNNLQJWRWRSHQ RYHUVODJHQKDQGHOLQJHQPHWJHYDDUOLMNHVWRIIHQ,QJHYDOYDQ'H7ULS%9ZRUGHQHHQDDQWDO KDQGHOLQJHQPHWJHYDDUOLMNHVWRIIHQXLWJHYRHUGZDDUYRRUUHJHOV]LMQRSJHQRPHQLQGH KLHURQGHUZHHUJHJHYHQ3*6ULFKWOLMQHQWHZHWHQ - 3*6³2SVODJYDQYHUSDNWHJHYDDUOLMNHVWRIIHQ´ - 3*6³9ORHLEDUHEUDQGVWRIIHQERYHQJURQGVHWDQNLQVWDOODWLHVHQDIOHYHULQVWDOODWLHV 8LWERYHQVWDDQGHEOLMNWGDWHULQJHYDOYDQ'H7ULS%9JHHQVSUDNHLVYDQHHQ%5=2HQRI %HYLLQULFKWLQJ:HOZRUGWJHZHUNWFRQIRUPGHUHOHYDQWHHLVHQFRQIRUP3*6HQ PLOLHXEHVFKHUPGHJHELHGHQHQVWLNVWRIGHSRVLWLH 'HOLJJLQJYDQGHLQULFKWLQJYDQ'H7ULS%9WHQRS]LFKWHYDQGHPLOLHXUHOHYDQWHJHELHGHQ 1DWXUDJHELHGHQHG
LVQDGHURQGHU]RFKW,QGHRPJHYLQJYDQ'H7ULS%9]LMQHQNHOH QDWXXUJHELHGHQJHOHJHQ%LQQHQHHQVWUDDOYDQNLORPHWHUEHYLQGW]LFKHHQRQGHUGHHOYDQ KHW1DWXUDJHELHGWHZHWHQGH³2RVWHOLMNH9HFKWSODVVHQ´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
'HVWLNVWRIGHSRVLWLHYDQZHJHGHGLYHUVHDFWLYLWHLWHQLVEHUHNHQGPHWKHWSURJUDPPD$HULXV 'HEHUHNHQLQJHQ]LMQDOVELMODJHELMGH]HDDQYUDDJJHYRHJG8LWGHXLWJHYRHUGH EHUHNHQLQJHQEOLMNWGDWGHWRWDOHELMGUDJHYDQGHLQULFKWLQJRSGHLQGHUXLPHRPJHYLQJ 7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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wPSOHPHQWHHUGELQQHQKDDURUJDQLVDWLHZDDULQGH SURFHGXUHVHQLQVWUXFWLHVYDVWJHOHJG]LMQPHWEHWUHNNLQJWRWELM]RQGHUHHQRQJHZRQH YRRUYDOOHQ(QNHOHYRRUEHHOGHQKLHUYDQELMOHNNDJHRIPRUVLQJYDQHHQERGHPEHGUHLJHQGH
VWRIZRUGWGLUHFWRSJHUXLPGFRQIRUPKHWLQFLGHQWHQPDQDJHPHQWELMEUDQGRIH[SORVLHLVPHW QDPHYDQEHODQJGDWKHW YHURQWUHLQLJG EOXVZDWHUNDQZRUGHQRSJHYDQJHQRSKHWWHUUHLQ +LHUWRHZRUGWGHWHUUHLQDIYRHUQDDUGHULROHULQJGLUHFWDIJHGLFKW UXLPWHOLMNHRQGHUERXZLQJ %HVWHPPLQJVSODQ =RDOVUHHGVDDQJHJHYHQLQSDUDJUDDILV'H7ULS%9WHEHVFKRXZHQDOVHHQEHGULMIPHW PLOLHXFDWHJRULH2SJURQGYDQGHYRRUORSLJHXLWVSUDDNLVRSGH]HORFDWLHGHYHVWLJLQJ YDQPD[LPDDOFDWHJRULHPRJHOLMN,QKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQLVLQDUWLNHORSJHQRPHQ GDWjPLOLHXFDWHJRULHsQKRJHUNDQZRUGHQWRHJHVWDDQDOVZRUGWDDQJHWRRQGGDW³KHW EHGULMIQDDUDDUGHQLQYORHGRSGHRPJHYLQJ «DOVPHGHJHWRHWVWDDQGHDDQJHJHYHQ PDDWJHYHQGHPLOLHXDVSHFWHQ JHDFKWNDQZRUGHQJHOLMNWH]LMQDDQGHLQOLGJHQRHPGH FDWHJRULHsQYDQGH/LMVWPHWEHGULMIVDFWLYLWHLWHQ³7HYHQVLVLQGLWDUWLNHORSJHQRPHQGDW KHW]HOIGHJHOGWYRRUEHGULMYHQGLHQLHWLQGH/LMVWYDQEHGULMIVDFWLYLWHLWHQ]LMQJHQRHPGPDDU ZHOQDDUDDUGHQLQYORHGRSRPJHYLQJYHUJHOLMNEDDU]LMQPHWZHORSJHQRPHQEHGULMYHQ ,QGH91*SXEOLFDWLHµ%HGULMYHQHQPLOLHX]RQHULQJ¶XLWLVDDQJHJHYHQZHONHDIVWDQGHQ DDQJHKRXGHQPRHWHQZRUGHQWRWHHQPLOLHXFDWHJRULHHQEHGULMI,QSDUDJUDDIYDQ KHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQLVGH]HSXEOLFDWLHRRNJHKDQWHHUG$DQJHJHYHQLVGDWGHDVSHFWHQ
JHXUJHOXLGVWRIHQJHYDDUPDDWJHYHQG]LMQYRRUGHPLOLHXLPSDFWRSGHRPJHYLQJHQGH DDQWHKRXGHQDIVWDQGWRWJHYRHOLJHEHVWHPPLQJHQPHWQDPHZRQLQJHQ9RRUHHQ PLOLHXFDWHJRULHEHGULMIEHGUDDJWGHPLQLPDDODDQWHKRXGHQDIVWDQGWRWZRQLQJHQ PHWHU9RRUHHQEHGULMILVGH]HDIVWDQGP$OVNDQZRUGHQDDQJHWRRQGGDWGH ZHUNHOLMNHDIVWDQGYDQHHQEHGULMIYRRUGH]HDVSHFWHQPHWHUEHGUDDJWLVYROGDDQDDQ GHYRRUZDDUGHXLWDUWLNHOYDQKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ 8LWYRRUJDDQGHSDUDJUDIHQHQRQGHUOLJJHQGHRQGHU]RHNHQEOLMNWKHWYROJHQGH
YRRU]LWWHUYDQGH$IGHOLQJ%HVWXXUVUHFKWVSUDDNYDQGH$IGHOLQJYDQGH5DDGYDQ6WDWHPHW]DDNQXPPHU 5GGIHEUXDUL
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
6WRIGHVWRIHPLVVLHYDQZHJH'H7ULSLVEHSHUNWHQZRUGWYHUGHUEHSHUNWGRRUGHLQ SDUDJUDDIDDQJHJHYHQ%%7PDDWUHJHOHQ'HVWRIHPLVVLHV]XOOHQGDDUGRRUQLHW EXLWHQGHWHUUHLQJUHQ]HQRSWUHGHQ'DDUQDDVW]LMQLQKHW$FWLYLWHLWHQEHVOXLWVWUHQJH YRRUVFKULIWHQRSJHQRPHQYRRUVWRIHPLVVLHELMGHRSHQRYHUVODJYDQLQHUWH JRHGHUHQ2RNKLHUPHHZRUGWVWRIRYHUODVWEXLWHQGHWHUUHLQJUHQ]HQYRRUNRPHQ - *HOXLGLQKHWDNRHVWLVFKRQGHU]RHNLVDDQJHWRRQGGDW o GHDDQJHYUDDJGHLQULFKWLQJLQSDVEDDULVLQGHJHOXLGV]RQHGLHLVRSJHQRPHQ LQKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQDDQJH]LHQGHELMGUDJHODJHURIJHOLMNLVDDQKHW EXGJHWZDWYRRUGLWSHUFHHOEHVFKLNEDDULV HQHUZRUGWYROGDDQDDQGH JHOXLGVYRRUVFKULIWHQXLWGHYLJHUHQGHYHUJXQQLQJ o RSPHWHUDIVWDQGPD[LPDDOG% $ LQUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNGHGDJ DYRQGHQQDFKWSHULRGHZRUGWJHSURGXFHHUG'LWNRPWRYHUHHQPHWGH QRUPULFKWDIVWDQGYRRUHHQFDWHJRULHEHGULMI +LHUPHHLVDDQJHWRRQGGDWGHLQULFKWLQJLQSDVEDDULVLQKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQHQ YHUJHOLMNEDDULVPHWGHJHOXLGLPSDFWYDQHHQPLOLHXFDWHJRULHEHGULMI -
-
*HXULQKHWJHXURQGHU]RHNLVLQJHJDDQRSGHHLVHQGLHLQKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ]LMQ JHIRUPXOHHUG'HGRRUJHPHHQWH8WUHFKWJHKDQWHHUGHJHXUQRUPLVRX(P (ULV DDQJHWRRQGGDWKLHUDDQZRUGWYROGDDQLQELMODJHILJXXUYDQKHWJHXURQGHU]RHN
*HYDDUHUYLQGWDOOHHQEHSHUNWHRSVODJYDQQLHWEUDQGEDDUJHYDDUOLMNDIYDOSODDWVHQ RSVODJYDQPD[LPDDOOLWHUGLHVHOROLHLQYLMIYHUVFKLOOHQGH,%&¶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
EULHIYDQJHPHHQWH8WUHFKWDDQ$IGHOLQJ%HVWXXUVUHFKWVSUDDNYDQIHEUXDULPHWNHQPHUN SDJLQDYDQ
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
EHVFKULMYLQJDFWLYLWHLWHQHQPLOLHXJHYROJHQDDQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%9WH8WUHFKW
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
7UL8WU:DER0LO
PHL
$DQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%96RSKLDODDQWH8WUHFKW
%LMODJH
$DQYUDDJ:DER'H7ULS%96RSKLDODDQWH8WUHFKW
%LMODJH