Rapport_HIP_Joods rechtsherstel-Nijkerk_EN
Tekst van het document
Research commissioned by the municipality of Nijkerk This research was conducted by Dr Anton van Renssen of Historytelling of Nijkerk. Researcher and author:
Dr Anton van Renssen
The copyright of this publication belongs to the commissioning party: the municipality of Nijkerk Illustration on cover: Synagoge Nijkerk, by Frans Kragt Hzn., 1955 (collection Jan Bijvank)
2
Table of contents Chaper 1
Introduction................................................................................................................... 5
Chapter 2
Assignment and conclusions ......................................................................................... 7
Chapter 3
Justification of the research method used ................................................................... 11
Step-by-step plan ................................................................................................................................................................................11 Verkaufsbücher and Jewish Farmlands Database ..........................................................................................................................12 Municipal archives and the (digital) land registry ............................................................................................................................13 Netherlands Property Administration Institute.................................................................................................................................13 Land registry ledgers..........................................................................................................................................................................14 Again: digital land registry .................................................................................................................................................................14 Notarial archive ..................................................................................................................................................................................14 NIOD: files of liquidated Nijkerk-based
companies..........................................................................................................................14 Joodsmonument.nl and Jokos files..................................................................................................................................................15 Jewish Agricultural Land Database ..................................................................................................................................................15 Restoration of rights ..........................................................................................................................................................................15
Chapter 4
Deprivation of rights, clearance of houses and taxes ................................................... 17
Nijkerk and the occupying forces ......................................................................................................................................................17 Reclamation along the river Laak ......................................................................................................................................................18 Deprivation of rights ...........................................................................................................................................................................19 Property transactions in the Gelders Archief (Gelderland Provincial Archive) ...............................................................................21 Vacant homes and clearances ..........................................................................................................................................................22 Role of Municipal Public Works Department in clearances.............................................................................................................22 Monitoring of vacant properties ........................................................................................................................................................23 Rental of vacated homes
...................................................................................................................................................................24 Taxes paid...........................................................................................................................................................................................26 Agricultural land .................................................................................................................................................................................27 Liquidation of Jewish businesses and property...............................................................................................................................27
Chapter 5 Restoration of rights ............................................................................................................ 30 Liberation and administrators ...........................................................................................................................................................30 Returnees in Nijkerk ...........................................................................................................................................................................31
3
Dealing with municipal staff ..............................................................................................................................................................34 Tax assessments for the years of occupation .................................................................................................................................34 Cost of repairs ....................................................................................................................................................................................35 Restoration of rights and sale of immovable property ....................................................................................................................35 Restoration of rights of Jos de Liver .................................................................................................................................................36 Restoration of rights Aaltje Speyer-Fortuijn......................................................................................................................................37 Restoration of rights various persons ...............................................................................................................................................38 Meiling family
.....................................................................................................................................................................................39 Municipal councillor Klaas Visscher .................................................................................................................................................40 Purchase of property and land by the municipality ..........................................................................................................................40 Reversing the liquidation of companies ...........................................................................................................................................41 Affairs of E. Cohen’s heirs .................................................................................................................................................................43 Closing words .....................................................................................................................................................................................44
Consulted sources and literature .......................................................................................................... 46
4
CHAPTER 1
Introduction The mayor of Nijkerk, Zwaantinus Bruins Slot, knew it for sure in December 1947: the municipality of Nijkerk carried out ‘no works’ for the Germans during the war. It had, of course, received assignments that it should have carried out.1 Bruins Slot himself had held off for as long as he could, and he only went into hiding – on two occasions – when he felt he had no other option. As soon as Nijkerk was liberated on 20 April 1945, he returned and resumed his duties as mayor. More than six years earlier, on 15 February 1939, he had taken office as mayor there at the age of 35. It was his first municipality. It is known that immovable property owned by Jewish Dutch citizens was stolen by the occupying forces and forcibly sold. The central question in this research is how the municipalities of Nijkerk and Hoevelaken dealt with immovable property owned by Jewish Dutch citizens. Is Bruins Slot's assertion from December 1947 correct? Did the municipality of Nijkerk indeed refrain from buying and selling homes and commercial property and farmland belonging to Jewish Dutch citizens during the Second World War? Was the municipality involved in restoration of the rights of its Jewish residents? And how did the municipality behave towards survivors and relatives of victims after the liberation?
Municipal boundaries To gain insight into the state of affairs within the municipality of Nijkerk, research was conducted into Jewish property holdings in the municipality of Nijkerk. This also covers properties in the former municipality of Hoevelaken. However, nothing appears to be known about Jewish property ownership in Hoevelaken. In contrast with Nijkerk, Hoevelaken had no Jewish residents during the Second World War. A search in the digitised Verkaufsbücher, an important source for property transactions during the occupation, showed no transactions in Hoevelaken. Only three files relating to Hoevelaken were found in the Netherlands Property Administration Institute (Nederlandse Beheersinstituut, NBI), but those files did not concern Jews. Two experts from Hoevelaken also argued that there were no Jews living in Hoevelaken, nor was there any immovable property in Jewish hands. While there may be more to this than meets the eye, it is highly unlikely that there were any Jewish properties in the former municipality of Hoevelaken.2 The search for Jewish property during the war in Hoevelaken was therefore ended.
The researcher and the supervisory committee This research was conducted by Dr Anton van Renssen, historian in Nijkerk. In his research, he was supervised by a committee. This consisted, in alphabetical order, of the following people: •
Sonja de Leeuw – emeritus professor of Media Culture, Utrecht University and representative of the NederlandsIsraëlitische Gemeente Amersfoort (Dutch-Israelite Community Amersfoort, NIGA)
•
Ab van Straalen - physiotherapist and someone with a lot of knowledge on Jewish Nijkerk, author of several publications
•
Dieter van de Castel – former civil-law notary
•
Saskia van den Berg-Ebbenhorst – curator Museum Nijkerk and project secretary
•
Marlous Diederiks – heritage adviser municipality of Nijkerk
•
Dion van Hooren – archivist municipality of Nijkerk
1
GAN, Minutes of the municipal council meeting, 3 December 1947, p.39.
2
This is confirmed by the historian Maarten Doude van Troostwijk, MA from Hoevelaken and the former civil-law notary Aart Veldhuizen, LLM
born in Hoevelaken: email to author, 26 October 2022.
5
•
Stefan Staartjes - policy advisor municipality of Nijkerk, supervisory committee chairperson
Structure of this report This report consists of five chapters. The structure was borrowed from the report on restoration of rights in the municipality of Apeldoorn.3 This introduction is followed by the assignment and conclusions in Chapter 2. Chapter 3 contains an explanation of the approach of this research. Chapter 4 deals with the deprivation of Jewish property rights and agricultural land rights, the clearance of homes in Nijkerk, the liquidation of Jewish businesses, the role of the Municipal Public Works Department and the handling of municipal taxes. Wherever possible, a chronological order of events will be used in this chapter. This applies in particular to the decision to first deal with the deprivation of property rights and thereafter the clearance of homes occupied by Jews. This choice means that components from various research questions are dealt with interchangeably. Chapter 5 deals with the restoration of rights after the war.
Wartime history and persecution of Jews in Nijkerk As in the rest of the Netherlands, there is great interest in local history during and after the Second World War in Nijkerk. This applies to a great extent to the history of the Jewish community in this town in the Veluwe region. Ab van Straalen has written extensively about the history of the Jewish community in 'Van jubileum naar catastrofe. De Joodse gemeenschap van Nijkerk in de periode 1926-1945’ (From anniversary to catastrophe. The Jewish community of Nijkerk in the period 1926-1945). However, the attitude of the municipal authorities during the war was barely discussed for a long time, especially in relation to Jewish residents. The municipality of Nijkerk, like all other Dutch municipalities, also complied with the request of the German occupying forces to provide the addresses of Jewish residents. In doing so, the municipality of Nijkerk also unwittingly contributed to the ingenious way – due to its concealed nature – in which the Germans structured the persecution of Jews in Dutch municipalities.4 Mayor Bruins Slot was unaware of the fact that the Germans were playing such a game, Rachel Hamburger argued in 2002.5 She was one of the few survivors of the Nijkerk Jewish community after the war.
People had known about the guiding role played by mayor Zwaantinus Bruins Slot for a long time, but it was not until 2020 that more detailed information about this was published.6 However, hardly anything was known about the handling of the property and possessions of the Jewish residents of Nijkerk who were murdered and of those who returned. It is one of the reasons why this research is taking place, following research conducted in other municipalities across the country.
3
W. van Meurs, P. Slaman and M. Oprel (et al.), ‘Joodse burgers in Apeldoorn: onteigening en rechtsherstel’ (Jewish citizens in Apeldoorn:
dispossession and restoration of rights) (Nijmegen, March 2022). 4
R. Schütz, De administratieve verhulling van het lot van vervolgden tijdens de Endlösung. Bureaucratische paradoxen bij het registreren,
verhullen en vernietigen van persoonsgegevens, in: Tijdschrift voor geschiedenis, (The administrative concealment of the fate of the persecuted during the Final Solution. Bureaucratic paradoxes in the registration, concealment and destruction of personal data) 135.1 (2022) 44. 5
Jos Bouten, ‘Wat is Nijkerk mooi geworden. Rachel Salomon-Hamburger op zoek naar Joods verleden’, (How beautiful Nijkerk has become.
Rachel Salomon-Hamburger looking for her Jewish past) publication medium unknown, 2002. 6
A. van Renssen, Gekkop. Hoe burgemeester Zwaantinus Bruins Slot Nijkerk de oorlog doorloodste’ (How mayor Zwaantinus Bruins Slot guided
Nijkerk through the war) (Nijkerk, 2020).
6
Chapter 2
Assignment and conclusions The grounds for this research into the role of the municipality with regard to deprivation and restoration of rights arose in 2019. At the time, the Central Jewish Council in the Netherlands (Centraal Joods Overleg) asked all municipalities with a former Jewish community to conduct such research. Six years earlier, a discovery in the Amsterdam archives had revealed that after the war, fines had been unjustly imposed on Amsterdam citizens returning from concentration camps, imprisonment or hiding for non-payment of ground rent.7 The City of Amsterdam started research into its own actions, conducted by the NIOD Institute for War, Holocaust and Genocide Studies. The municipalities of The Hague, Rotterdam and Utrecht followed suit. More and more municipalities are following the call for this research. In spring 2020, the journalistic platform Pointer published about the deprivation of rights and theft of Jewish property during the Second World War. This was a stimulus for many municipalities to commission such research. Various studies have revealed that Jewish survivors and relatives often had to go to great lengths to recover their possessions.8 There were also instances where additional tax assessments were levied for periods in which the Jewish owners had been unable to occupy the properties due to deportation.
The question is whether such situations also occurred in the municipality of Nijkerk. The research concerns homes owned by Jewish Dutch citizens, as well as commercial property and land ownership. The research question is divided into four sub-questions. The first two questions concern the administrative responsibility of the municipality of Nijkerk in dealing with Jewish property during the war and other deprivation of rights, such as furniture theft. Did the municipality buy immovable property, including at an excessively low price, as often occurred? The last two questions focus on the attitude of the municipality of Nijkerk regarding the restoration of rights after the war. The research also covers people who were involved with the municipality of Nijkerk as employees or councillors. Because the ownership of immovable property of Jews in Nijkerk was limited, a decision was made to draw up an inventory of all the property.
Questions 1.
In what ways was the municipality of Nijkerk involved in the sale, deprivation or acquisition of Jewish private and/or commercial immovable property during the Second World War?
2.
In what ways was the municipality involved in the deprivation of rights of Jewish residents of Nijkerk during the Second World War? This may include (as an example, but not limited to) the role of municipal services such as the Municipal Public Works Department and the police. It also includes the role of the municipality as an employer.
3.
If the municipality obtained properties through the forced sale or deprivation of rights of Jewish residents, what was its role in dealing with them after the Second World War? How did the municipality act after the Second World War in the case of the restoration of rights to immovable property belonging to Jewish residents of Nijkerk that had been sold or leased to third parties? This includes the role of municipal services, such as the municipal housing service and mental health services, and the reception of returned Nijkerk Jews.
4.
Did the municipality impose any form of tax (such as street tax and sewerage charges) or other costs (for home improvements, for example) on Jewish survivors or families of victims after the Second World War? This concerns
7
https://www.amsterdam.nl/bestuur-organisatie/organisatie/overige/stichting-ita/
8
M.-J. Vos and S. ter Braake, Rechtsherstel na de Tweede Wereldoorlog van geroofd Joods onroerend goed (Restoration of rights to looted
Jewish property after World War II)(Amsterdam, 2013) 25.
7
levies or payments calculated for the time when they did not (or could not) make use of the plots in question themselves.
Conclusions about the deprivation of rights during the Second World War 1.
In what way was the municipality of Nijkerk involved in the sale, deprivation of rights to or acquisition of Jewish private and/or commercial property during the Second World War?
The research shows that the municipality of Nijkerk was not involved in the sale of Jewish property or commercial properties belonging to Jewish owners during the Second World War. The municipality of Nijkerk occasionally mediated between new tenants and the new landlord who had bought or was managing the houses. The latter was done by the Algemeen Nederlands Beheer van Onroerende Goederen (General Dutch Property Management Authority, ANBO). This organisation sold a number of properties. It remained the manager of other properties and continued to collect rent from them. The mayor of Nijkerk once sought permission from the ANBO to allow a property, the rights to which had been deprived, to be rented by one of the officers of the municipality of Nijkerk. A councillor's wife bought two houses from a Jewish resident. The municipal councillor in question was Klaas Visscher. It emerged after the war that he made that purchase on behalf of his wife at the request of the Jewish family. Jewish businesses in Nijkerk were liquidated by order of the Omnia-Treuhandgesellschaft m.b.H. This concerned small businesses. They were not put under management like large companies, but their activities were completely terminated by the Omnia-Treuhandgesellschaft m.b.H. These were often businesses of Jewish owners who had their business attached to or close to their house.
The municipality of Nijkerk played no role in this, except for providing information requested on commercial property by the Omnia-Treuhandgesellschaft m.b.H.
2.
In which way was the municipality involved in the deprivation of rights of Jewish residents of Nijkerk during the Second World War? This may include (as an example but not limited to) the role of municipal services such as the Municipal Public Works Department and the police. It also includes the role of the municipality as an employer.
The municipality of Nijkerk did not purchase or confiscate movable property from Jewish residents. However, the research does show that the municipality was involved in the clearance of homes occupied by Jews after the residents had gone into hiding or were taken away. The house clearances were usually ordered by organisations such as the ANBO, the Niederländische Grundstückverwaltung (NGV) or the Omnia-Treuhandgesellschaft m.b.H. Requests or orders from these kinds of organisations were what Mayor Bruins Slot referred to after the war. The clearance of Jewish homes was in the hands of the Municipal Public Works Department of the municipality of Nijkerk. An inventory of household effects from various houses was drawn up and stored by this department, so that the cleared houses could be rented out. This was done by order of the German authorities. The Nijkerk branch of the military constabulary sealed vacant homes of Jewish citizens of Nijkerk in 1942 and 1943. Mayor Bruins Slot no longer had direct authority over the military constabulary by that time. The Germans did hold him responsible for maintaining public order. One of these public order tasks was ordering the clearance and sealing of Jewish homes. As an employer, the municipality had to lay off one Jewish officer on redundancy pay.
As far as we are aware, that redundancy pay was paid out until the deportation of this officer.
8
As far as we know, the municipality itself did not rent out any houses to Jewish citizens of Nijkerk. The only Jewish municipal officer who was dismissed lived in a rented house owned by a private citizen. However, on or shortly after the day this Jewish official was forced to leave, a colleague of his did make a request to the German authorities to be allowed to rent the house to a newly appointed municipal officer. Head of the Municipal Public Works Department Evert van Rootselaar secured the household effects of Samuël de Liver, owner and occupant of Spoorstraat 30, by hiding them. The possessions of the butcher Isaäk Hammelburg were buried in a milk can by the Visscher family and returned to the family after the war.
Conclusions on the restoration of rights 3.
If the municipality obtained properties from forced sales or the deprivation of rights of Jewish residents, what was its role in dealing with them after the Second World War? How did the municipality act after the Second World War when restoring rights to immovable property that had been rented out to third parties? We include the role of municipal services in this, such as the municipal housing service and mental health services.
The research shows that, as far as we know, the municipality of Nijkerk did not endeavour to restore immovable property to any returnees. For questions about immovable property, the municipality referred to the Politieke Opsporings Dienst (Political Investigation Service) in Harderwijk, civil-law notaries or administrators appointed by the NBI. In most cases, matters were brought to an end through amicable settlements, although this sometimes took several years. In this respect, the way Nijkerk dealt with stolen Jewish property and Jewish possessions is no different from that of most other Dutch municipalities. Two homes were bought by Ms Visscher-Van Koeverden, wife of municipal councillor Klaas Visscher, at the request of the Hammelburg family during the war. Both homes were permanently acquired by her in 1952 in return for payment of the increased value. At the same time, the research shows that several Jewish residents of Nijkerk said they were received with indifference or outright coldness after their return. Some heirs of Jewish property owners have had an extremely difficult time in Nijkerk. Some could not return to their (parental) homes because other people lived there who had not been or could not be evicted. In other cases, tenants were evicted after legal proceedings.
There was also a Jewish heiress who missed out on part of the lost rental income from a house owned by her father and rented out by the ANBO during and after the war. Other tenants, including the municipality of Nijkerk, did not pay rent on time. In the case of the municipality, this concerned the rent paid by the Social Services Department for a tenant of Nieuwstraat 12, owned by the Fortuijn family and, after the war, after restoration of rights, owned by Aaltje Speyer-Fortuijn. The mention of the name of the Meiling family in various records concerning goods belonging to the Cohen family, and the purchase of a warehouse from the Fortuijn family after the war relates to two sons of the alderman Anthonie Meiling.
9
4.
Did the municipality impose any form of tax (such as street tax or sewerage charges) or other costs (such as for home improvements) on Jewish survivors or families of victims after the Second World War? This concerns levies or payments calculated for the time when they did not (or could not) make use of the plots in question themselves.
The municipality of Nijkerk collected taxes from new owners of dispossessed Jewish properties during and after the war. The ANBO also paid those taxes during the war for homes subject to deprivation of rights it had rented out. Tax assessments from the war years were not charged to heirs of the murdered Jews. After the war, taxes were collected for post-war years from the prepared accounts of the absent Jews. This is evident from financial balance sheets that were drawn up by administrators appointed on behalf of the NBI. At the same time, rents for those properties were credited to those balance sheets. After the ANBO was liquidated, outstanding assessments were declared irrecoverable by the municipality in 1947. Assessments from post-war years that had not been paid by the ANBO were transferred to administrators who were appointed to preside over the estates of absent Jews, most of whom had been murdered. One case emerged during the research in which a tax assessment was imposed for the year 1944. That concerned land tax on the properties Singel 20 and Singel 22 belonging to the E. Cohen family, though that was a state tax. No further information was found which indicates that the municipality charged other costs, such as for home improvements. As far as the latter is concerned, these were paid after the war from the current accounts the administrators managed.
Those costs were partly reimbursed by the Dutch government. As for Mayor Bruins Slot's remark from December 1947, with which this report begins: it is largely correct. Most actions taken by municipal officers involved following regulations of the German authorities. However, the municipality did take action quickly by asking the German authorities to rent the vacant rental house of municipal officer Mozes Spanjar again to a newly appointed municipal officer. Bruins Slot's post-war remark also does not apply as far as the cool reception of some returned Jewish residents of Nijkerk is concerned.
10
CHAPTER 3
Justification of the research method used The structure of this academically sound research is based on the structure of research with similar questions conducted for other municipalities.
Step-by-step plan 1.
Mapping out owners of plots and Jewish owners and war buyers a.
Jewish property owners during the war
b.
Jewish owners of farmland during the war
2.
Theft or forced sale of Jewish property
3.
Restoration of rights after the war
By consulting other research and talking to researchers, it was possible to quickly draw up an initial selection of archives to be consulted. There are various types of archives. The first choice was archives of political and administrative bodies, as well as administrative and judicial archives.9 After consulting, among others, Prof Wim van Meurs, professor at Radboud University Nijmegen, supplemented by data from Vos and Ter Braake, it was decided to consult the following archives if possible – not necessarily in the following order.10 1
Municipal Archives, Nijkerk: Minutes of the Municipal Executive and other relevant municipal files: minutes, lists of resolutions, annual reports and correspondence of the municipal council and the Municipal Executive - consulted
2
Land registry, can be consulted digitally via the municipality of Nijkerk - consulted
3
Database Joodse Landbouwgronden (Jewish Farmlands Database), Jewish Cultural Quarter Amsterdam consulted
4
Netherlands Property Administration Institute (National Archives, The Hague) - Verkaufsbücher - files Nijkerk residents and owners of Jewish property outside Nijkerk - consulted
5
Archive of the Council for the Restoration of Rights (National Archives in The Hague) - consulted
6
Archives of the province of Gelderland - accessed
7
Algemeen Nederlands Beheer van Onroerende Goederen (General Dutch Management of Property - ANBO)11 (NIOD, Amsterdam, Kadastermuseum (Land Registry Museum) Arnhem) - not consulted
8
Central Archives for Special Criminal Jurisdiction (National Archive, The Hague) - not consulted
There are two reasons why the latter two archives were not consulted. The first is that sufficient information could be extracted from the other archives to answer the research questions posed. The second is that exploratory research showed that the archives at the NIOD did not contain relevant information on the ANBO and the CABR provided little relevant new information. To gain insight into the types of ownership of plots, homes and business premises during and after the war, it was first necessary to clarify which property in the municipality of Nijkerk was Jewish-owned. A start in this regard was Ab van Straalen's
9
W. van Meurs, P. Slaman and M. Oprel (et al), 29.
10
Vos and Ter Braake, 32-47.
11
Algemeen Nederlands Beheer van Onroerende Goederen (ANBO) headed by NSB members. According to the authors of the study on the
municipality of Apeldoorn, the records of the ANBO are partly located at the NIOD Institute for War, Holocaust, and Genocide Studies in Amsterdam. Parts have also been recovered at the Kadastermuseum (Land Registry Museum) in Arnhem. See: W. van Meurs, P. Slaman and M. Oprel (et al), 30.
11
publication into the history of the Jewish community in Nijkerk from 1926 to 1945.12 This publication contains an address list of homes of Jewish residents of Nijkerk. That list does not state which properties were owned by the residents and whether there were more Jewish property owners.
Verkaufsbücher and Jewish Farmlands Database An initial source consulted for the research was the digitised Verkaufsbücher. These are 17 notebooks drawn up during the war by the German organisation in charge of managing homes subject to deprivation of rights.13 That was the Niederländische Grundstückverwaltung (NGV, also known as the Nederlandse Administratie van Onroerende Goederen)14 in The Hague. In sales ledgers, the NGV kept detailed records of all transactions of Jewish immovable property. A total of 7,109 transactions are listed in the Verkaufsbücher.15 This includes transactions in the municipality of Nijkerk. In August 1941, the German occupying forces ruled that all Jewish residents in the Netherlands had to give up their property. After the Jewish owners were deported, the property was taken into management by the NGV. This organisation outsourced management of the property to various institutions. An important organisation was the Algemeen Nederlands Beheer van Onroerende Goederen (ANBO), founded in 1941 by estate agent and NSB member Dirk Hidde de Vries.16 De Vries sold some properties on behalf of the NVG and then collected a percentage of the proceeds. In other cases, it remained the ANBO administrator who collected rental income during the war.
Some Jewish homes in Nijkerk were also sold by the ANBO on behalf of the NVG.17 Records in the land registry ledgers that were kept in the municipal archives show that houses were put under the management of the NVG, while the Verkaufsbücher states that the same houses were sold by the ANBO. NGV transferred the proceeds to the Vermögensverwaltungs und Renteanstalt (VVRA), which in turn transferred the money to the 'looting bank' Lippmann-Rosenthal (Liro). At that 'looting bank', Jewish property owners were obliged to hold an account, where they were required to deposit assets.18 The purchase of the houses the NGV stole from Jewish Dutch people was partly financed with the help of the Landelijke Hypotheekbank (National Mortgage Bank). The initial start-up capital of this bank was provided by the director of De Nederlandsche Bank, prominent NSB member Meinoud Rost van Tonningen.19 Apart from transactions of Jewish immovable property, the NGV also registered mortgages of Jewish individuals.20 Several buyers of Jewish property arranged their mortgage
12
A. van Straalen, Van jubileum naar catastrofe. De Joodse gemeenschap van Nijkerk in de periode 1926-1945, (From anniversary to catastrophe. The Jewish community of Nijkerk in the period 1926-1945) (Nijkerk, 2007). 13 Following M-J. Vos, I have chosen to use the term deprivation of rights with regard to homes because expropriation is usually used by the government measure in spatial planning processes. Moreover, it corresponds to the term 'restoration of rights' used after the war. See: M.J. Vos, Maarten-Jan Vos, Joods vastgoed in Winterswijk 1943-1950. Rapport over de roof en gedwongen verkoop van vastgoedbezit van Joden en de rol van de gemeente Winterswijk bij roof en rechtsherstel tijdens de Tweede Wereldoorlog en de jaren daarna, (Jewish property in Winterswijk 1943-1950. Report on the looting and forced sale of property owned by Jews and the role of the Winterswijk municipality in looting and restoration of rights during World War II and the years thereafter) (Winterswijk, 2022) 8. 14
NA, NBI, 2.09.16.13, inv.no. 168595, Spinosa Cattela-Vorst, M.H.H., Arnhem, E.P. Reijers, civil-law notary, Deed of Restoration of Rights, 29
October 1946. 15
Spreadsheet Verkaufsbücher, downloaded from the website of the National Archives: https://www.nationaalarchief.nl/onderzoeken/open-
data/indexen; https://pointer.kro-ncrv.nl/verkaufsbucher-administratief-boekwerk-als-startpunt-voor-aangrijpende-oorlogsverhalen; W. van Meurs, P. Slaman and M. Oprel (et al), 30; Vos and Ter Braake, 32. 16 R. te Slaa, De houding van de gemeente Den Haag tegenover Joodse eigenaren van onroerend goed 1940-1955 (The attitude of The Hague municipality towards Jewish property owners 1940-1955) (zp., 2016) 17. 17 Archive Y. de Liver, Contract of sale Spoorstraat 30 and 32, 14 December 1943. 18
Vos and Ter Braake, 21, for link with Liro see note 43; NA, NBI, 2.09.16.03, inv.no. 55160, Cohen, E., Nijkerk, Overview initial assets 20 June
1945 and Cash Overview 1-1 to 31-12 1946; 18 Te Slaa, 10. 19
Vos and Ter Braake, 21-22.
20
Vos and Ter Braake, 22.
12
loans through wealthy individuals.21 This was also the case in Nijkerk. The Verkaufsbücher provide an overview of the Jewish owners deprived of their rights, the war buyers and other parties involved. Eleven property transactions of Nijkerk property are registered in seventeen preserved Verkaufsbücher.
Municipal archives and the (digital) land registry The second step taken during this research was consulting the archives of the municipality of Nijkerk. What immediately stood out when preparing to consult them was the special inventory numbers created on topics concerning Jewish residents of Nijkerk during the war. For example, there is a separate file on the administration of homes and household effects. The next step was to consult the digital land registry with the help of the municipality of Nijkerk. This should reveal who owned which homes during and after the war. Since the names of Jewish residents were known, it might have been possible to find more property in the land registry than they owned. Land registry ledgers often contain details on the management of the NGV, and later details of the new owners. They usually also reflect the post-war restoration of rights. However, some ‘intermediary buyers' were not registered in the land registry, as homes sometimes changed hands on the same day of purchase.22 Looking for the history of properties, a number of notarial deeds were consulted in the digital land registry. It soon became clear that research via the digital land registry is very laborious. To work more efficiently, a two-tier approach was therefore chosen: first, all relevant files in the NBI would be examined.
It was expected that it would be possible to find owners of land and property in Nijkerk more easily in the NBI files, with possible indications of property sales and post-war rehabilitation of rights. There are land registry ledgers in the municipal archive of Nijkerk showing the ownership history of properties. It is a kind of shadow register of the digital land registry. It was expected that, based on this register, it would be possible to trace Jewish owners of properties, including possible forced sales during World War II. Before consulting this source, the files of the Netherlands Property Administration Institute were consulted first.
Netherlands Property Administration Institute The archive of the Netherlands Property Administration Institute (Nederlandse Beheersinstituut, NBI) is at the National Archives in The Hague. It includes records of twenty thousand administrators who were appointed for so-called 'absentees'. Those 'absentees' included thousands of Jewish Dutch citizens who were deported and murdered during the war. Many administrators prepared statements of assets at the instructions of the NBI. Those statements can be found in the files. Immovable property that belonged to the assets of an 'absentee' was also included in these. Besides these statements, correspondence with civillaw notaries can also often be found in the files. Various files show whether and which heirs claimed immovable property and whether restoration of rights took place. The latter often began with a certificate of succession, which can be found in various NBI files. The inventory of the NBI archive is searchable by keywords via the website of the National Archives. A total of 19 NBI files were consulted in which Nijkerk appears. These included files of both Jewish residents of Nijkerk and Jews outside Nijkerk who owned property in the municipality, according to the Verkaufsbücher.
In some cases, these files offer relevant information about the ownership of properties, but are sometimes very brief, such as that of Nijkerk municipal officer Mozes Spanjar.
21
Vos and Ter Braake, 99.
22
Vos and Ter Braake, 20-24.
13
Land registry ledgers As expected, the NBI files provided much valuable information on Jewish property owners in the municipality of Nijkerk. There turned out to have been more Jewish-owned properties than was known up until now. With the collected data in hand, the land registry ledgers of the municipality of Nijkerk were then examined, which are organised according to name. This research in turn revealed new addresses of property owned by Jews. As it turned out, the butcher couple Abraham and Sara Hamburger-Rood not only owned Oosterstraat 18, as known from Van Straalen's research, but also a barn and land on Oostereind. Incidentally, this shadow archive shows that after this couple's suicide in 1941, these properties were sold to Nijkerk business people: the butcher Gerrit Woukersz. Bos and the café owner Aart Willemszn. van den Bosch.23 The same archive revealed that some Jewish residents of Nijkerk did not own their homes, such as the municipal inspector Spanjar and the vegetable trader Mok. That also confirmed a pre-existing suspicion.
Again: digital land registry Having reached this point in the research, it had now become clear what happened to some properties during and after the war. In order to collect the necessary information from the remaining properties, the more intensive search of the digital land registry had to be resumed. Based on this research, new details were found. This was repeated after questions arose at the second meeting of the Supervisory Committee on 15 December 2022 about the exact course of events surrounding the so-called 'Jewish bath house', the mikveh, on Brink.
Notarial archive The search for additional information about the mikveh in the digital land registry did not yield any relevant information. In order to nevertheless obtain the necessary information on possible transactions during the war involving the property in which the mikveh was located, committee member Dieter van de Castel consulted the archives of the Nijkerk firm of civil-law notaries Van der Weij at the request of the Supervisory Committee. This civil-law notary office holds the archives of Reijers, the civil-law notary at that time. With the same goal in mind, he then contacted the firm of civil-law notaries Kuiper & Van 't Spijker Notariskantoor in Putten, which holds the archive of Putten civil-law notary Neervoort. No records were found from either investigation relating to this location.24
NIOD: files of liquidated Nijkerk-based companies As in the rest of the country, Jewish businesses in Nijkerk were registered and eventually liquidated after the ordinance by the occupying forces on 12 March 1941. The question that can be asked here is whether commercial property was also part of these liquidations. Many Nijkerk businesses were small enterprises, often located in or next to residential houses. A lot of data about liquidated companies can therefore be found in personal files in the archives of the Dutch Management Institute. For more specific research on the liquidation of Nijkerk companies, the archives of the Omnia-Treuhandgesellschaft m.b.H. and the Deutsche Revisions- und Treuhand A.G. were consulted. These turned out to contain four files of Nijkerk entrepreneurs that were consulted at the NIOD in Amsterdam.25
23
GAN, Land Registry ledgers, Ledger 11, article 6321.
24
Emails from D.C. van de Castel to P.M. Cooper (cc to author), 6 February 2023; H. de Lange to D.C. van de Castel, 13 February 2023.
25
NIOD, inv. no. 094, Archive Omnia Treuhandschaft m.b.H. See also:
www.archieven.nl/nl/zoeken?miview=inv2&mivast=0&mizig=210&miadt=298&micode=094&milang=nl - consulted on 20 September 2022.
14
Joodsmonument.nl and Jokos files The website Joodsmonument.nl yielded some good background information on individuals found in the above archives. Many Jewish owners of property in Nijkerk are listed there, and the files state whether they were murdered during the war, and if so when. This source was used insofar as the data was not already known, as was the case with the Van Esso family from Amsterdam. For a number of the people listed on this website, the archive indicated that a so-called Jokos file (Jokos-dossier) exists for them. These files largely contain financial records and data on inventories of homes. At the third meeting of the Supervisory Committee, it was decided to consult three files, as there might be a link to the municipality in them. These were the files of municipal officer Mozes Spanjar, rag-and-bone men Izaak and Jetje Fortuijn, and shopkeeper Samuel de Liver.26 To access these files, a written request was submitted to the director of Joods Maatschappelijk Werk (Jewish Social Work) in Amsterdam. That request was granted, but because the files were being digitised during the research period, we were only able to see the Jokos files of Fortuijn and De Liver.
Jewish Agricultural Land Database Apart from examining forced sales of residential and commercial properties, research was also conducted into forced sales of (agricultural) land. The most important archive for this is that of the Goedkeuring van Overdracht van Joodse landbouwgronden (Approval of Transfer of Jewish agricultural land). On 27 May 1941, it had already been determined that Jewish-owned agricultural land had to be sold by 1 September of the same year.27 To gain insight into the forced sale of Jewish agricultural land, the archives of the Bureau voor de Goedkeuring van overdracht van Joodse landbouwgronden (Office for Approval of Transfer of Jewish agricultural land) were consulted. The archives of the Bureau voor de Goedkeuring en Pachtbureaus/Grondkamers (Office for Approval and Leasing Offices/Agricultural Tenancies Authorities) are in the National Archives in The Hague. The survey of Jewish agricultural land sold during the war is available digitally at the Jewish Cultural Quarter in Amsterdam.28 This archive records one transaction in which a plot of land within the municipality of Nijkerk was sold.
Restoration of rights A next step taken was to explore the restoration of rights. Previously mentioned archives such as those of the municipal archives, including the land registry ledgers, the digital land registry, but especially the files of the Netherlands Property Administration Institute, were sufficient for this. Brief research in the archives of the Council for the Restoration of Rights (Raad voor het Rechtsherstel) in the National Archives in The Hague did not yield any relevant information. After an initial discussion with the Supervisory Committee (Begeleidingscommissie), some of the above archives were consulted once again. This was particularly true of the NBI files and the municipal archives. Intensive use was also made of Van Straalen's study on the Nijkerk Jewish community before, during and after the Second World War. Several entries in the Gelders Archief (Gelderland Provincial Archive) were also examined at the request of the Supervisory Committee.
26
This concerns the Jokos files 18368 (Spanjar), 5999 (I. Fortuijn) and 9031 (S. de Liver).
27
Vos and Ter Braake, 13.
28
NA, 2.11.08.01 Inventory of the archives of the Directie van de Landbouw: Afdeling Grond- en Pachtzaken (Directorate of Agriculture:
Department of Land and Tenancy Cases), (1906) 1935-1964; Jewish Cultural Quarter, ‘Database Joodse landbouwgronden’ (Database of Jewish agricultural land).
15
A discussion was held with surviving former Nijkerk resident Louk de Liver from Amersfoort to obtain additional information and to find out if he knew any people who might need to be involved in the research. 29 In spring 2023, advertisements were placed for the same purpose in the Nieuw Israëlitisch Weekblad and the quarterly magazine Benjamin of the organisation Joods Maatschappelijk Werk (Jewish Social Work). These asked whether relatives of Jewish residents of Nijkerk could provide information on the municipality's handling of Jewish immovable property. Some surviving relatives were also contacted by letter. There were ultimately three responses. The first was from Yaël de Liver, who shared information about her great-grandfather Levi de Liver and his brothers from Nijkerk, Philip and Samuel and their heiress Jos de Liver. A message was received from Benjamin Salomon, son of Roza Salomon-Hamburger, from Israel that he had no relevant information for the research. He did, however, thank me for the effort made with the research to shed light on the matter.30 There was no substantive response from Ms Amalia Har-Toov, daughter of Jos de Liver, after initial email contact.31
29
On September 26, 2023, just before the completion of this research, Louk de Liever died in his hometown of Amersfoort.
30
Email from B. Salomon to S. Staartjes, municipality of Nijkerk, 3 June 2023: 'As far as I am aware, from conversations with my late mother
(who passed away 4 years ago), I have no relevant information concerning the investigation. Nevertheless, I thank you for conducting such research and for approaching me.' 31
Email from M. Diederiks, municipality of Nijkerk, to Amalia Har-Toov, 13 September 2023.
16
CHAPTER 4
Deprivation of rights, clearance of houses and taxes Now that it is clear which sources were consulted, we come to the actual research findings. In this chapter, we will first briefly discuss the role of mayor Bruins Slot and the attitude of the Nijkerk civil service and police. We will then discuss the deprivation of Jewish property rights. We will do that using the Verkaufsbücher and other sources, such as NBI files and the land registry ledgers in the Nijkerk municipal archives. We will then turn our attention to Jewish property that was managed but not sold. Next, the theft of commercial Jewish property and agricultural land will be discussed. We will then cover the clearing of homes occupied by Jews and the reallocation of empty homes. Finally, we will look at the taxation that took place during the war.
Nijkerk and the occupying forces The municipality of Nijkerk was under the direction of mayor Zwaantinus Bruins Slot during the war. This young accountant from Hoogeveen had been appointed to his first municipality as mayor in 1939 and was explicitly anti-German. He was horrified that the local democratic order with city council and aldermen had to give way to an administrative apparatus under a monocratic leadership: his own.32 In 1941, this so-called 'führer principle' was introduced nationwide, replacing democratic constitutional law. From that time on, mayors were assigned all the administrative duties of aldermen, the municipal council and municipal committees. They were, however, under the supervision of higher bodies, such as the Commissaris der Provincie (Commissioner of the Province) - which later became the Commissaris van de Koning (King's Commissioner).33 However, the mayor considered the aldermen to still be in office.34 The same was true for the civil-law notary Reijers, as evidenced by two notarial deeds from 1942, by means of which Meiling sold agricultural land in the Arkemheen polder to his son Albert, and a house and a warehouse on Nieuwstraat to his son Gerrit, respectively. Both deeds identified Meiling senior as an alderman.35 Jewish municipal officers had been suspended by then.
All 'non-Aryan' government personnel had been dismissed in accordance with a circular letter dated 21 November 1940. The officers would continue to receive partial pay.36 In Nijkerk, this measure affected one officer. That was municipal inspector Mozes Spanjar, who lived with his family at Van Delenstraat 15. He was initially a butcher in Rijssen, but moved to Nijkerk in 1938, where he entered the employment of the municipality as an assistant inspector that year.37 As an inspector, his responsibilities included checking the hygiene in slaughterhouses. After his resignation, he was paid redundancy pay.38
32
Van Renssen, 93-94.
33
P. Romijn, Burgemeesters in oorlogstijd. Besturen tijdens de Duitse bezetting (Mayors in wartime. Local administration during the German
occupation) (Amsterdam, 2006) 291. 34
Van Renssen, 95.
35
Digital Land Registry, Copy of the public register - Hyp4 dl 2298 no. 128 series ARNHEM. The premises in question were known as section B
2591. Those premises were not Jewish property. 36
Romijn, 184-185.
37
https://www.Joodsmonument.nl/nl/page/129937/mozes-spanjar; https://oorlogsdodendinkelland.nl/slachtoffers/oude-gemeente-
denekamp/spanjar-mozes/ 38
NA, NBI, 2.09.16.02, inv.no 4872, Bartus Reuyl, H., file Spanjar, M., Nijkerk [PD10 1175], 18 January 1954, A. Gottschalk to the Raad voor het
Rechtsherstel (Council for the Restoration of Rights), afd. Voorzieningen Afwezigen (Provisions for Absentees department), The Hague.
17
With regard to the police, other measures were taken. The Germans largely abolished the municipal police and the mayors were relieved of most of the responsibilities for local policing.39 At the beginning of the war, the Nijkerk police force had five municipal rural constables led by an Inspector of Police.40 During the reorganisation, that police force was merged with the military constabulary, whose headquarters for the Nijkerk division was in Arnhem. By March 1943, the entire reorganisation of the Dutch police force had been completed. Mayor Bruins Slot wrote about it in his diary that month: ‘The mayors have now become 'local leaders' and as such they are and remain in charge of the police, but organisationally they have nothing to do with the military constabulary. Orders are given to the highest in rank and this officer must carry out these orders as he sees fit. I will definitely be able to manage with Van der Krol. He is a good police officer and a likeable guy. Today (afternoon), I officially bid farewell to the municipal rural constables at the council chamber and addressed them in the presence of the military constabulary. The senior constable Peterkamp thanked me for everything on behalf of the rural constables and Van der Krol also promised good cooperation on behalf of the military constabulary.
He saw in me, he said, the mayor and chief of police, and his attitude would be consistent with that.'41 Van der Krol's words show that Bruins Slot was still seen by the Nijkerk military constabulary division as the chief of police. The mayor owed this mainly to his personal authority. Organisational changes did nothing to change that. ‘The rural constables then transfer,' Bruins Slot wrote in his diary on 6 December 1942 about the reorganisation. 'However, implementation decrees are yet to come. The mayor remains chief of police but can only give business orders.'42 What did remain among his duties was maintaining public order. Consequently, in the war years that followed, the mayor was involved in actions by the rural constables, as evidenced by a report to the mayor by municipal rural constables Hendrikus de Graaf and Pieter van der Veer.43 Actions by the rural constables were also reported to mayor Bruins Slot, such as sealing empty Jewish houses.44
Reclamation along the river Laak Bruins Slot took a special initiative in September 1942. This concerned a last-ditch attempt on his part to save Jewish residents of Nijkerk from deportation. His plan was to put the Jewish men to work at a reclamation project of the Heibid.ij near the Laak, the river between Nijkerkerveen and Hoevelaken, on the border of Gelderland and Utrecht. Through a good contact at the Sicherheitsdienst in Arnhem, SD Hauptscharführer Willy Bühe, he managed to arrange that they could stay in their houses and work on the reclamation project during the day. When this trick no longer worked and the families were nevertheless ordered to leave, he visited SS Hauptsturmführer Ferdinand aus den Fünten in Amsterdam. Among other things, the latter was responsible for the deportation of Jews from the Netherlands. This attempt failed, as he had more or less expected.45 Bruins Slots' efforts do indicate the positive attitude he took towards Jewish residents of Nijkerk.46
39
Romijn, 425.
40
GAN, Municipality of Nijkerk 1920-1947, E 588, personnel file H. Diepenbroek, BS to Secretary General of the Department of Home Affairs, 4
January 1941. 41
Van Renssen, 103-104.
42
Van Renssen, 103.
43
GAN, Municipality of Nijkerk 1920-1947, E 271, municipal rural constables H. de Graaf and P.T. van der Veer, official report on the distribution
of perishable foodstuffs from the homes of Jews, 12 April 1943. 44
GAN, Municipality of Nijkerk 1920-1947, E 271, municipal rural constable J.A. Peterkamp to mayor Z. Bruins Slot, 29 October 1943.
45
Gelders Archief (GA), Entry 0039 Provincial Executive, Inv. no. 6212 Expropriation of municipal property, 1850, 1946-1947 - 08.4. Municipalities,
6357 Nijkerk, 1925-1949, Gelderland Provincial Public Works and Water Management Department to the Provincial Executive, 26 September 1945. 46
Van Renssen, 140-150.
18
But how did he and his officers deal with the property of Jewish residents of Nijkerk after their departure on 9 April 1943? The municipal archives, the land registry and the NBI provide the necessary information on this.
Deprivation of rights The ANBO assumed management of several homes owned by Jews. The ANBO in particular, which included a Utrecht branch office of Hague-based estate agent De Vries, a member of the NSB, appears to have played an important role in managing and renting out dispossessed Jewish homes during and even after the war. This firstly concerned the 11 houses listed in the Verkaufsbücher. Some properties sold by the NGV through the ANBO, which do appear in the Verkaufsbücher, were owned by the wealthy Amsterdam Van Esso family. This family owned the properties Spoorstraat 14 to 28 and also Stationsweg 20. The latter house was destroyed and demolished during the war.47 Spoorstraat 14 to 24 were owned by Samuel and Sientje of Esso-Van Esso. Spoorstraat 26 and 28 were owned by their son Berthold Isador van Esso. Samuel and Sientje van Esso did not survive the war. Samuel died a natural death in Amsterdam on 26 May 1942. His wife died during a train transport from Bergen-Belsen to Theresienstadt on 18 April 1945. Their son was killed in Elburg on 13 April 1945. His wife Louise Roozendaal did survive the war.48 Spoorstraat 14 and 16 were sold to 'V.d. Leck' from Amersfoort on 16 July 1943 on behalf of the NVG through the ANBO.49 Spoorstraat 18 and 20 were bought during the war by J. Staal, who lived at Spoorstraat 20.
He bought those houses on 15 June 1943, according to the Verkaufsbücher. That same day, Staal possibly resold those houses to Willem van Essen from Voorthuizen, although, according to a 1953 letter from Nijkerk civil-law notary Beekman, he bought them from the ANBO.50 Spoorstraat 22 to 28 were bought by Arie Schakel in Soesterberg on 1 April 1943, according to civil-law notary Beekman in 1953. However, the Verkaufsbücher lists N. van Kuijk of Veenendaal as the buyer of numbers 22 and 24, but on the same date.51 However, it is known that the Verkaufsbücher are not complete, as not all dispossessed properties were sold. Further research at the NBI and in the municipal archives also shows that this concerns properties owned by Jewish owners in Nijkerk. This shows that a total of 43 homes and business premises in Nijkerk were Jewish-owned. In addition, seven more properties were found that were inhabited by Jews, but owned by non-Jews. Some addresses were not listed in the Verkaufsbücher, but researched via the digital land registry. These are Holkerstraat 9 and 13. The first property was owned by the butcher Henri Hamburger. During the war, it was not sold but rented out by the ANBO.52
47
NA, NBI, 2.09.16.04, inv.no. 200633, Esso-van Esso, S. van, Amsterdam, administrator Meyer van Esso, Report File no. 4169/3629/div/Ny//es,
11 April 1946. 48
www.Joodsmonument.nl/nl/page/154909/sientje-van-esso-van-esso - accessed 8 August 2022;
https://www.Joodsmonument.nl/nl/page/675323/over-het-lot-van-louis-gast-en-berthold-isador-van-esso - Two articles in Oud Meppel, March 2015 and June 2015, accessed 8 August 2022; NA, NBI, 2.09.16.04, inv.no. 200633, Esso-van Esso, S. van, Amsterdam, civil-law notary C.E. Massee, Amsterdam, Declaration of inheritance and justice, 3 September 1951. 49