Zienswijze Z-20 - 094486 anoniem 1



6WLFKWLQJ$FKPHD5HFKWVELMVWDQG 3RVWEXV $&$SHOGRRUQ

$$17(.(1(1 5 

 'HOODHUWZHJ /HLGHQ

*HPHHQWH+RHNVFKH:DDUG *HPHHQWHUDDG 3RVWEXV

 7HOHIRRQ  )D[  NODQWHQVHUYLFH#DFKPHDUHFKWVELMVWDQGQO ZZZDFKPHDUHFKWVELMVWDQGQO

($28'%(,-(5/$1'     'DWXP 

2QV]DDNQXPPHU

%HKDQGHOGGRRU

PHL 

5

0Z=3.UXLYHU

2QGHUZHUS

 *URQGHQ]LHQVZLM]HRQWZHUSEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ



8ZNHQPHUN



GLGRHQYU

 0RRNKRHN



    *HDFKWHKHHUPHYURXZ  2SDSULO]RQGLNQDPHQVGHKHHU15''H=HHXZ0RRNKRHN$&LQ022.+2(. 15''H=HHXZ $&LQ022.+2(. FOLsQWHHQSURIRUPD]LHQVZLM]H,QGH]HEULHIYRHULNGHJURQGHQDDQ  &OLsQWLVKHWQLHWHHQVPHWKHWRQWZHUSEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ0RRNKRHN &OLsQWZRRQWGLUHFWJUHQ]HQGDDQKHWSODQJHELHG'LWSODQKHHIWYRRUFOLsQWQDGHOLJHJHYROJHQ+HWSODQ LVLQVWULMGPHWHHQJRHGHUXLPWHOLMNHRUGHQLQJ  'HVLWXHULQJYDQGHZRQLQJHQLVRQGXLGHOLMN 8LWGHYHUEHHOGLQJEOLMNWQLHWGHVLWXHULQJYDQGHYRRU]LHQHZRQLQJHQ(U]LMQLPPHUVJHHQERXZYODNNHQ RSJHQRPHQLQGHYHUEHHOGLQJ2SYDOOHQGLVGDWDUWLNHOYDQGHSODQUHJHOVZHOYHUZLMVWQDDU ERXZYODNNHQ,QGHWRHOLFKWLQJELMKHWRQWZHUSEHVWHPPLQJVSODQLVHHQVFKHWVRSJHQRPHQZDDUXLWNDQ ZRUGHQDIJHOHLGZDWGHVLWXHULQJZRUGW]LH)LJXXU   

5HNHQLQJQXPPHU ,%$1 1/5$%2 .YN$SHOGRRUQ 



9HUYROJRSGHEULHIYDQ

PHL

%HVWHPGYRRU

%ODGQXPPHU





 )LJXXUVFKHWVVLWXHULQJZRQLQJHQ SWRHOLFKWLQJELMKHWRQWZHUSEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ   8LWKHWDNRHVWLVFKRQGHU]RHNYDQ.UDDLM$NRHVWLVFK$GYLHVEXUHDXGGPDDUWEOLMNWHHQ DIZLMNHQGHVLWXHULQJ]LH)LJXXU 

 )LJXXUVLWXHULQJERXZYODNNHQ]RDOVDDQJHJHYHQLQKHWDNRHVWLVFKUDSSRUWRSS



9HUYROJRSGHEULHIYDQ

PHL

%HVWHPGYRRU



%ODGQXPPHU



2YHULJHQVYDOWRSSDJLQDYDQGHWRHOLFKWLQJWHOH]HQGDWGHQLHXZHZRQLQJHQZRUGHQWRHJHYRHJG ³GDDUZDDUDOWLMGDOEHERXZLQJKHHIWJHVWDDQ´'HVFKHWVHQHQGHWHNVWYDQSDJLQDYDQGH WRHOLFKWLQJVSUHNHQHONDDUWHJHQ  'RRUGDWGHVLWXHULQJYDQGHZRQLQJHQRQGXLGHOLMNLVLVKHWRQWZHUSRQ]RUJYXOGLJ+LHUPHHRQWQHHPWX FOLsQWGHNDQVGHXJGHOLMNRSKHWRQWZHUSWHUHDJHUHQ  &OLsQWEHQDGUXNWHHQJURWHYRRUNHXUWHKHEEHQYRRUVLWXHULQJRSGHSOHNYDQGHEHVWDDQGHEHERXZLQJ ]RDOVRRNJHQRHPGRSSDJLQDYDQGHWRHOLFKWLQJELMKHWRQWZHUSEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ  5LFKWDIVWDQGHQWRWEHGULMIVEHVWHPPLQJ 2S0RRNKRHNLVHHQEHGULMIJHYHVWLJG+HWJHOGHQGHEHVWHPPLQJVSODQJHHIWDDQGDWHUHHQEHGULMI YDQPD[LPDDOFDWHJRULHPDJZRUGHQJHYHVWLJG'DWKRXGWLQGDWLQSULQFLSHPLQLPDDOPHWHU DIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHYUDDJRIVSUDNHLVYDQJHPHQJGJHELHG DIVWDQGPRHW]LMQWXVVHQGH EHGULMIVEHVWHPPLQJHQHHQQLHXZHZRRQEHVWHPPLQJ'H]HDIVWDQGZRUGWQLHWJHKDDOG6WHUNHUQRJ GHZRRQEHVWHPPLQJJUHQVWGLUHFWDDQGHEHGULMIVEHVWHPPLQJ,QGDWJHYDOGLHQWWHZRUGHQRQGHU]RFKW HQJHPRWLYHHUGGDWYRRUGHDVSHFWHQJHXUJHOXLGVWRIHQJHYDDUJHHQEH]ZDDULVWHJHQKHW YHUNOHLQHQYDQGHULFKWDIVWDQG'LWLVXLWVOXLWHQGJHEHXUGYRRUKHWDVSHFWJHOXLG%RYHQGLHQEOLMNWXLWKHW DNRHVWLVFKUDSSRUWGDWWHUSODDWVHYDQGHEHGULMIVEHVWHPPLQJRSGLWPRPHQW]HOIVHHQEHGULMIYDQ

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



9HUYROJRSGHEULHIYDQ

PHL

%HVWHPGYRRU



%ODGQXPPHU



 +HWSODQ]RUJWYRRUSDUNHHURYHUODVW =RDOVKLHUERYHQDDQJHJHYHQZRUGWJHHQUHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQPHWKHWJURWHDDQWDO% %EHGGHQGDW KHWRQWZHUSPRJHOLMNPDDNW8LWGHWRHOLFKWLQJELMKHWRQWZHUSEOLMNW]HOIVGDWVOHFKWVSDUNHHUSODDWVHQ YRRUKHWJHKHOHSODQZRUGHQJHUHDOLVHHUG'LWWHUZLMOGH&52:QRUPHQZDDUXELMDDQNQRRSWHHQ DDQWDOYDQSDUNHHUSODDWVHQSHUZRQLQJYRRUVFKULMYHQ'DDUERYHQRSGLHQHQYROGRHQGH SDUNHHUSODDWVHQWHZRUGHQJHUHDOLVHHUGWHQEHKRHYHYDQGH% %¶V:LMYUDJHQXGDQRRNPHWHHQ YRRUZDDUGHOLMNHYHUSOLFKWLQJLQGHSODQUHJHOVYDVWWHOHJJHQGDWHUYROGRHQGHSDUNHHUSODDWVHQRSHLJHQ WHUUHLQNRPHQ  &OLsQWPDDNW]LFK]RUJHQRPGHSULYDF\ +HWLVQLHWGXLGHOLMNZDDUGHZRQLQJHQSUHFLHV]LMQYRRU]LHQPDDUXLWGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHVFKHWVHQEOLMNW GDWGHPHHVW]XLGHOLMNHZRQLQJHUJGLFKWELMGHZRQLQJYDQFOLsQWLVLQJHWHNHQG&OLpQWPDDNW]LFK GDDURP]RUJHQRPLQNLMNLQ]LMQZRQLQJ'HLQNLMNPDDNWHHQHQRUPHLQEUHXNRS]LMQSULYDF\ $DQSDVVLQJYDQKHWSODQLVQRGLJRPGHSULYDF\WHEHVFKHUPHQ2PLQNLMNWHYRRUNRPHQYHU]RHNW FOLsQWGHDIVWDQGWXVVHQ]LMQZRQLQJHQGHJHSODQGHZRQLQJHQWHYHUJURWHQ  &OLsQWYHU]HW]LFKWHJHQKHWEHSODQWLQJVSODQ &OLsQWKHHIWLQGHKXLGLJHVLWXDWLHODQJVGHKXLGLJHEHERXZLQJYULM]LFKWWRWDDQGH(UDVPXVEUXJ+HW

YDOWLQKHWYRRUOLJJHQGHSODQRSGDWGHYULMH]LFKWOLMQHQYRRUGHYRRU]LHQHQLHXZERXZZRUGWJHNRHVWHUG (FKWHUZRUGWDDQGHHYLGHQWHZHQVYDQFOLsQWRSYULMH]LFKWOLMQHQYRRUELMJHJDDQPHWKHW EHSODQWLQJVSODQ&OLsQWYHU]RHNWGDQRRNKHWSODQDDQWHSDVVHQ]RGDWDFKWHU]LMQZRQLQJJHHQ ERPHQKHHVWHUVZRUGHQJHSODQWHQFOLsQWYULMXLW]LFKWEHKRXGW  8NXQWSODQVFKDGHYRRUNRPHQGRRUHHQDDQSDVVLQJYDQKHWSODQ (HQJRHGHUXLPWHOLMNHRUGHQLQJYUDDJWGDWXKHWQDGHHOYRRURPZRQHQGHQ]RNOHLQPRJHOLMNKRXGW2RN GDDURPYUDJHQZLMXDQGHUHPRJHOLMNHORFDWLHVWH]RHNHQZDDUJHHQRIPLQGHUSODQVFKDGHLV  &OLsQWYUDDJWXKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQQLHWYDVWWHVWHOOHQ ,QLHGHUJHYDOYUDDJWKLMXUHNHQLQJWHKRXGHQPHWGH]H]LHQVZLM]HHQKHWSODQDDQWHSDVVHQ  %HORIPDLOPLMJHUXVWDOVXQRJYUDJHQKHEW 8EHUHLNWPLMRSWHOHIRRQQXPPHU±0DLOHQNDQQDDU NODQWHQVHUYLFH#DFKPHDUHFKWVELMVWDQGQO2QV]DDNQXPPHULV5:LOWXGLWQXPPHUDOWLMG QRHPHQDOVXEHOWRIPDLOW":LMNXQQHQXGDQVQHOOHUKHOSHQ 



9HUYROJRSGHEULHIYDQ

PHL

%HVWHPGYRRU



0HWYULHQGHOLMNHJURHW

 0Z=3.UXLYHU MXULVW

%ODGQXPPHU