21023.5 - Vastgestelde bijlage bij Kernboodschap 'Implementatie Omgevingswet Samen ruimte maken' dec 2017
Tekst van het document
,03/(0(17$7,(20*(9,1*6:(7
,1+28'623*$9(
,1/(,',1*
$DQOHLGLQJ
'RHOYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHW
,PSOHPHQWDWLHPHHUGDQHHQWHFKQLVFKMXULGLVFKHYHUWDOLQJ
,QYRHULQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ
3URMHFW,PSOHPHQWDWLH2PJHYLQJVZHW
3URMHFWLQWZHHIDVHQ
6DPHQZHUNLQJ%HVW9HOGKRYHQ
7KHPDVHVVLHYRRUGHUDGHQHQFROOHJHV
9HUZHYHQKHLGUXLPWHOLMNHQVRFLDDOGRPHLQ
/HHVZLM]HU
6$0(158,07(0$.(1
.(8=(60$.(1
2PJHYLQJVYLVLH
D /RNDOHRPJHYLQJVYLVLHFRQIRUPHUHQDDQUHJLRQDOHDIVSUDNHQ
E %HOHLGI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJLQWHJUHUHQLQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH
F 5ROYDQGHJHPHHQWHSHUJHELHGYHUVFKLOOHQG
2PJHYLQJVSODQ
D 5HJHOVHHQYRXGHHQGXLGLJHQUHGHQHUHQYDQXLWGHEHGRHOLQJ
E 9HUJXQQLQJVYULMPHOGLQJRIYHUJXQQLQJVSOLFKW
F 9HURUGHQLQJHQYRRU]RYHUUHOHYDQWRSQHPHQ
G 5HJHOVRSJHELHGVQLYHDXXLWJDQJVSXQW
H 8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHWRHSDVVHQ
I 2QGHU]RHNVODVWHQGRRUVFKXLYHQ
J +HWPHQJSDQHHOWRHSDVVHQ
3DUWLFLSDWLH
5ROUDDGFROOHJH
D 'HOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQGHOHJHUHQ
E 9RRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWGHOHJHUHQ
'LYHUVHRQGHUZHUSHQ
D (HQFRPPLVVLHYRRUQLHWZHWWHOLMNYHUSOLFKWHWDNHQ
E %HJURWLQJRSERXZDDQSDVVHQ
F $DQVOXLWHQELMKHW'LJLWDDO6WHOVHO2PJHYLQJVZHW '62
%LMODJH7KHPDVHVVLHFROOHJHHQUDGHQ
%LMODJH%HOHLGI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJ
%LMODJH&DWHJRULHsQYDQJHYDOOHQZDDUELMJHHQYHUNODULQJYDQJHHQEHGHQNLQJHQ
+22)'678.,1/(,',1* $DQOHLGLQJ +HWRPJHYLQJVUHFKWLVRPYDQJULMNHQFRPSOH['H2PJHYLQJVZHWLVLQYRRUEHUHLGLQJHQEXQGHOWDOGH ZHWJHYLQJRSKHWJHELHGYDQGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJ'DDUGRRU]LMQPLQGHUUHJHOVQRGLJHQZRUGWGH ZHWJHYLQJGXLGHOLMNHUHQRYHU]LFKWHOLMNHU2RNELHGWGH2PJHYLQJVZHWPHHUUXLPWHYRRULQLWLDWLHYHQHQORNDDO PDDWZHUN'HZHWKHHIWGDDUQDDVWJHYROJHQYRRUGHZHUNZLM]HELQQHQGHJHPHHQWH'H2PJHYLQJVZHWLV DDQJHQRPHQLQGH7ZHHGHHQ(HUVWH.DPHU2SGLWPRPHQWZRUGHQGH,QYRHULQJVZHWGH0LQLVWHULsOH 5HJHOLQJHQGH$OJHPHQHPDDWUHJHOHQYDQEHVWXXU $0Y%¶V HQGH$DQYXOOLQJVZHWWHQYRRUEHUHLG :LMEHUHLGHQRQVYRRURSGHNRPVWYDQGHQLHXZHZHW'LWLVQRGLJRP x GHRUJDQLVDWLHRSWLMGNODDUHQLQJHULFKWWHKHEEHQRPWHNXQQHQZHUNHQELQQHQGHNDGHUVYDQGH 2PJHYLQJVZHW x WHNXQQHQZHUNHQRYHUHHQNRPVWLJGHGRHOVWHOOLQJHQYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHWHQ x WHNXQQHQZHUNHQPHWGHLQVWUXPHQWHQXLWGH2PJHYLQJVZHW 2PGHRUJDQLVDWLHLQVSLUDWLHULFKWLQJHQKRXYDVWWHJHYHQLVKHWLQGLWVWDGLXPDOYDQEHODQJNRHUVWH EHSDOHQ'LWGRHQZHGRRUHHQNHUQERRGVFKDSPHWERXZVWHQHQ PLVVLHV YDVWWHVWHOOHQ'H]HELHGWGHEDVLV RPNHX]HVWHPDNHQYRRUGLHRQGHUGHOHQZDDUGHJHPHHQWHDIZHJLQJVUXLPWHKHHIW+LHUELMPRHWHQZHRQV
UHDOLVHUHQGDWKHWHHQSURFHVLVGDWQDGHUHLQYXOOLQJNULMJWZDQQHHUGH$PY%¶VGHILQLWLHI]LMQHQGHWHNVWHQ YDQGH0LQLVWHULsOH5HJHOLQJHQEHNHQG'LWGRFXPHQWELHGWULFKWLQJPDDUWLMGHQVKHWSURFHVEOLMIWHUFRQVWDQW DDQGDFKWYRRUYHUEHWHULQJHQQLHXZHPRJHOLMNKHGHQ 'RHOYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHW +HWPRWWRYDQGHZHWLVµ5XLPWHYRRURQWZLNNHOLQJZDDUERUJHQYDQNZDOLWHLW¶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
QLHWDOOHHQHHQMXULGLVFKHYHUDQGHULQJ+HWZHUNYHOGYDQGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJYHUDQGHUWLQJULMSHQG'LW
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sQGHGLQJHQGLH ZHVRIWHUH]DNHQQRHPHQ 'DDQ4XDFNHUQDDW ,QYRHULQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ 'H9HUHQLJLQJ1HGHUODQGVH*HPHHQWHQ 91* KHHIWWHURQGHUVWHXQLQJYDQKHWLPSOHPHQWDWLHWUDMHFWYLHU LQYRHULQJVVWUDWHJLHsQXLWJHZHUNW x x x x
&RQVROLGHUHQGGHQRRG]DNHOLMNHZLM]LJLQJHQFRQIRUPGHZHWLQYRHUHQYDQXLWHHQLQWHUQHIRFXV &DOFXOHUHQGJHEUXLNPDNHQYDQGHUXLPWHGLHGHZHWELHGWZDDUGDWQDDIZHJLQJYDQEDWHQHQ NRVWHQDDQZLMVEDDUYRRUGHOHQRSOHYHUW 2QGHUVFKHLGHQGJHEUXLNPDNHQYDQGHUXLPWHGLHGHZHWELHGWRPLQVSHFLILHNHJHELHGHQKHW YHUVFKLOWHPDNHQ 9HUQLHXZHQGJHEUXLNPDNHQYDQGHUXLPWHGLHGHZHWELHGWRPYDQXLWRSJDYHQDQGHUVWHZHUNHQ
7LMGHQVGLYHUVHVHVVLHVPHWGHUDDGVOHGHQFROOHJHOHGHQHQPHGHZHUNHUVLVQDJHGDFKWRYHUGH]H LQYRHULQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ+LHUXLWEOLMNWGDWKHWYDQEHODQJLVRPRSHHQYHUQLHXZHQGHPDQLHUQDDUGH LPSOHPHQWDWLHWHNLMNHQ:DDUQRGLJNDQRSRQGHUZHUSHQELMJHVWHOGZRUGHQQDDUppQYDQGHDQGHUH VWUDWHJLHsQ'H]HOLMQLVEDVLVJHZHHVWYRRUGLWGRFXPHQW
3URMHFW,PSOHPHQWDWLH2PJHYLQJVZHW
3URMHFWLQWZHHIDVHQ +HWSURMHFWZRUGWLQWZHHIDVHQXLWJHYRHUG 2ULsQWDWLHHQNRHUVEHSDOHQ 8LWZHUNLQJ ,QIDVH]LMQZHJHwQVSLUHHUGGRRU'DDQ4XDFNHUQDDW2RNKHEEHQZHRQVYHUGLHSWLQ GHJHHVWYDQ GH 2PJHYLQJVZHWGH$0Y%¶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x VQHOGHLQKRXGYDQDOOHUHOHYDQWHZHWHQUHJHOJHYLQJGRRUJURQGHQ x JH]DPHQOLMNHELMHHQNRPVWHQ]LMQHIILFLsQWHU x NRVWHQGHOHQ x OHUHQYDQHONDDUHQPHWHONDDU x GHOHQYDQHUYDULQJHQHQYHUQLHXZHQGHLGHHsQ x VOXLWDDQELMJHHVWYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHWPHHUUHJLRQDOHVDPHQZHUNLQJ x VOXLWDDQELMGHVDPHQZHUNLQJVDIVSUDNHQYDQ%HVWHQ9HOGKRYHQHQJULMSHQGHNDQVRPQLHWDOOHHQ
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x 'HHHUVWHELMHHQNRPVWLVEDVLVLQIRUPDWLHJHJHYHQRYHUGH2PJHYLQJVZHWHQKHHIW'DDQ 4XDFNHUQDDWRSJHURHSHQRPDDQGHVODJWHJDDQPHWGHQLHXZHZHWHQNDWKHGUDOHQWHJDDQ ERXZHQ ³*DNDWKHGUDOHQERXZHQ´LVHHQYHUKDDORYHUGHDQJVWRP NDWKHGUDOHQWHERXZHQ&RQWUROHOHLGWWRWDQJVWYRRUULVLFR HQJHEUHNDDQSDVVLHGLHQRGLJLVYRRULQQRYDWLHHQJURHL :HPRHWHQHONDDUOHUHQDIUHNHQHQHQYHUWURXZHQ]RGDWHU UXLPWHYULMNRPWRPPRRLHGLQJHQWHPDNHQ 'DDQ4XDFNHUQDDW
x
'HWZHHGHELMHHQNRPVWVWRQGLQKHWWHNHQYDQKHWLQIRUPHUHQRYHUGHQLHXZH2PJHYLQJVZHWHQ GHYUDDJZDWGLWEHWHNHQWYRRUGHUROOHQYDQKHWFROOHJHHQGHUDDG
1DGH]HWZHHLQIRUPHUHQGHELMHHQNRPVWHQLVHUHHQGULHWDOWKHPDVHVVLHVJHZHHVWZDDURSHHQLQWHUDFWLHYH PDQLHUDDQGHKDQGYDQYUDJHQVWHOOLQJHQFDVXVVHQHQYRRUEHHOGHQQDJHGDFKWLVRYHUHHQDDQWDO VSHFLILHNHWKHPD¶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sUHQLV /HHVZLM]HU +RRIGVWXNYHUZRRUGWGHNHUQERRGVFKDS'H]HNHUQERRGVFKDSZRUGWRQGHUVWHXQGGRRUUXLPWHPLVVLHV(HQ
KRXYDVWRPDQGHUVWHJDDQGHQNHQHQZHUNHQELQQHQGHJHPHHQWH2SEDVLVYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHWHQGH ELMEHKRUHQGH$0Y%¶VLVEHNHNHQRSZHONHRQGHUZHUSHQVSUDNHLVYDQDIZHJLQJVUXLPWH8LWGH]HDQDO\VH YROJWGDWRYHUGLYHUVHRQGHUZHUSHQNHX]HVJHPDDNWNXQQHQZRUGHQ,QKRRIGVWXN]LMQGH]HNHX]HVLQ EHHOGJHEUDFKW3HURQGHUZHUSLVHHQWRHOLFKWLQJHQDGYLHVRSJHQRPHQ
+22)'678.6$0(158,07(0$.(1 'HHHUVWHJURWHPLVVLHLVLQWHUQJHULFKWPHWHHQH[WHUQHIRFXV$OVJHPHHQWHPRHWHQZHOHUHQUXLPWHWH JHYHQRPVDPHQUXLPWHWHPDNHQ'LWYUDDJWRPHHQDQGHUHPDQLHUYDQGHQNHQHQZHUNHQ'HEDVLV KLHUYRRULVWHYDWWHQLQGHYROJHQGHUXLPWHPLVVLHV
'HPLVVLHVEHSDOHQGHVWUDWHJLHKRHZHRPJDDQPHWGHUXLPWHGLHGH2PJHYLQJVZHWRQVELHGW
72(/,&+7,1*
$&7,(6
5XLPWHYRRUHONDDU 6DPHQZHUNHQ (LJHQDDUVFKDS 0HGHYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN 0LMQJHPHHQWH ,QWHJUDDO (UYDULQJHQGHOHQ 9RHOHQHQWKXLVYRHOHQ
2PJHYLQJVYLVLH x &RQIRUPHUHQDDQUHJLRQDOHDIVSUDNHQ x ,QWHJUHUHQEHOHLG 3DUWLFLSDWLH x 0LQLPDOHHLVHQZRUGHQJHVWHOG
58,07(0,66,(
'XUIORVWHODWHQ 9HUWURXZHQ %RXZHQRSHONDDU 0LQGHUUHJHOV 6LPSHOKRXGHQ
2PJHYLQJVSODQ x 5HJHOVHHQYRXGHHQGXLGLJHQ UHGHQHUHQYDQXLWGHEHGRHOLQJ x 9HUJXQQLQJVYULMPHOGLQJRI YHUJXQQLQJVSOLFKWWHUXJWUHNNHQGH RYHUKHLG x 9HURUGHQLQJHQI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJ LQRPJHYLQJVSODQ x *HELHGVJHULFKWEHVWHPPHQ 5ROUDDGFROOHJH x 'HOHJHUHQGHOHQYDQKHW RPJHYLQJVSODQ x 'HOHJHUHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLW 'LYHUVHRQGHUZHUSHQ x 2SERXZEHJURWLQJDDQSDVVHQ
0DDNGHUXLPWHPHH 8LWQRGLJHQ 3DUWLFLSDWLH 6DPHQGRHQ 0HHPDNHQ *DDQYRRUNZDOLWHLW 6DPHQERXZHQ
2PJHYLQJVSODQ x 8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHWRHSDVVHQ x 2QGHU]RHNODVWHQGRRUVFKXLYHQ x 0HQJSDQHHOJHEUXLNHQ 3DUWLFLSDWLH x 0LQLPDOHHLVHQZRUGHQJHVWHOG 'LYHUVHRQGHUZHUSHQ x &RPPLVVLHYRRUQLHWZHWWHOLMNHWDNHQ
'XUIWHYHUQLHXZHQ ,QQRYDWLHI 2SHQVWDDQ 7RHNRPVWJHULFKW %OLNYRRUXLW .HX]HVPDNHQ
2PJHYLQJVSODQ x 8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHWRHSDVVHQ x 2QGHU]RHNODVWHQGRRUVFKXLYHQ 'LYHUVHRQGHUZHUSHQ x 'LJLWDDO6WHOVHO2PJHYLQJVZHW VOLPPHYROJHU
'XUIWHSUREHUHQ 5XLPWHRPIRXWHQWH PDNHQ 0DDWZHUN )OH[LELOLWHLW :HQGEDDUKHLG 5XLPWHYULMPDNHQRP PRRLHGLQJHQWHPDNHQ &UHDWLHI 6DPHQGHUXLPWH EHSDOHQ
2PJHYLQJVYLVLH x 'HUROYDQGHJHPHHQWHSHUJHELHG EHSDOHQ 2PJHYLQJVSODQ x *HELHGVJHULFKWEHVWHPPHQ x 0HQJSDQHHOJHEUXLNHQ
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pQYDQGHEHODQJULMNHVSHHUSXQWHQYDQGHZHWLVGHPRJHOLMNKHLGYDQ ORNDOHDIZHJLQJVUXLPWH+LHUYRRU]LMQGLIIHUHQWLDWLHPDDWZHUNHQ LQQRYDWLHQRGLJ2PGLWRSHHQJRHGHPDQLHUYRUPWHJHYHQOLJWHHQ
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ppQYLVLHGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH
$OKHWUHOHYDQWHEHOHLGYRRUGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJLVJHwQYHQWDULVHHUG ]LHELMODJH 'HLQVWHHNLV JHNR]HQRPDOKHWUHOHYDQWHEHOHLGYRRUGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJRSWHQHPHQLQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH2SGLH PDQLHUZRUGWKHWGRHOYDQGHZHWRPVDPHQKDQJWXVVHQGLYHUVHEHOHLGVYHOGHQWHUHDOLVHUHQKHWEHVWH ZDDUJHPDDNW .HX]H $OKHWUHOHYDQWHEHOHLGYRRUGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJLQWHJUHUHQLQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH]RGDWHUJHHQ VHFWRUDDOEHOHLGPHHU+LHUELMLVELMODJHXLWJDQJVSXQWELMKHWRSVWHOOHQYDQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH
F
5ROYDQGHJHPHHQWHSHUJHELHGYHUVFKLOOHQG
7RHOLFKWLQJ 'HPDDWVFKDSSLMYHUDQGHUWHQGDDUPHHRRNGHUROYDQGHRYHUKHLG=RLVGHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHWUHQGGDWGH YHUKRXGLQJWXVVHQRYHUKHLGHQLQZRQHUVDDQKHWYHUDQGHUHQLVYDQKLs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
LQHHQDQGHUJHELHGZLOGHJHPHHQWHZHOOLFKWEHKRXGHQHQEHVFKHUPHQ .HX]H 'HUROYDQGHJHPHHQWHNDQSHUJHELHGYHUVFKLOOHQG]LMQ,QGH2PJHYLQJVYLVLHZRUGWDDQJHJHYHQZHONHURO SHUJHELHGKHWEHVWSDVW
2PJHYLQJVSODQ +HWRPJHYLQJVSODQYHUYDQJWKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ+HWRPJHYLQJVSODQLVXLWJHEUHLGHU=RPRHWHQGH YHURUGHQLQJHQGLHEHWUHNNLQJKHEEHQRSGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJZRUGHQRSJHQRPHQ2RNNXQQHQUHJHOV YRRUDUFKLWHFWXXUGXXU]DDPKHLGHQJH]RQGKHLGLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQZRUGHQJHVWHOG'RRUGH]H UHJHOJHYLQJVDPHQWHYRHJHQLQpp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µPHQJSDQHHO¶RIRSHQQRUPHQ9RRUKHWZHORIQLHWGRRUVFKXLYHQYDQ RQGHU]RHNVODVWHQYRRUKHWZHUNHQPHWYHUJXQQLQJVYULMHPHOGLQJSOLFKWLJHRIYHUJXQQLQJVSOLFKWLJH
DFWLYLWHLWHQHQGHPRJHOLMNKHLGRPPHHUJHELHGVJHULFKWWHEHVWHPPHQ D 5HJHOVHHQYRXGHHQGXLGLJHQUHGHQHUHQYDQXLWGHEHGRHOLQJ 7RHOLFKWLQJ 'H2PJHYLQJVZHWKHHIWDOVpp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ppQRPJHYLQJVSODQ]RGDWYRRULHGHUHHQGXLGHOLMNLVZDWHURSHHQEHSDDOGH ORFDWLHPRJHOLMNLV 'RRUDOOHUHJHOVRSKHWJHELHGYDQGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJLQppQRPJHYLQJVSODQRSWHQHPHQYHUPLQGHUW KHWDDQWDOUHJHOV8LWHHQHHUVWHLQYHQWDULVDWLHYDQGHUHJHOVRYHUGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJEOLMNWGDWHU x HHQYHHOKHLGDDQEHJULSVEHSDOLQJHQLV x GDWLQYHUVFKLOOHQGHUHJHOJHYLQJ EHVWHPPLQJVSODQYHURUGHQLQJHQ
KHW]HOIGHLVJHUHJHOGRIMXLVW WHJHQVWULMGLJKHGHQ]LMQRSJHQRPHQ x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
.HX]H 8LWJDQJVSXQWHQUHJHOV x DOOHHQDOVGLWQRRG]DNHOLMNLVYDQXLWKHWDOJHPHHQEHODQJ x UHGHQHUHQYDQXLWGHEHGRHOLQJGHUHJHOPRHWELMGUDJHQDDQKHWJHHQMHHUPHHZLOEHUHLNHQ x GXUYHQORVWHODWHQHQWHYHUWURXZHQUHJHOVWHUYRRUNRPLQJYDQPRJHOLMNHLQFLGHQWHQSDVVHQKLHU QLHWELM x HHQYRXGLJHUHQGXLGHOLMNHUZDDUELMMXULGLVFKHMXLVWKHLGDDQGDFKWVSXQWEOLMIW x UHNHQLQJKRXGHQPHWGHEHKRHIWHYDQLQZRQHUVRQGHUQHPHUVHQPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHRUJDQLVDWLHV x ZHUNHQPHWppQVHWUHJHOVYRRUGHUXLPWHOLMNHRPJHYLQJZDDUELMSHUVRRUWJHELHGDDQYXOOLQJHQRI DDQVFKHUSLQJHQNXQQHQJHOGHQ x JHHQWHJHGHWDLOOHHUGHUHJHOVRSVWHOOHQRP]REHWHULQWHNXQQHQVSHOHQRSGHDFWXDOLWHLW x DDQVOXLWHQELMEHJULSVEHSDOLQJHQXLWGHQDWLRQDOHZHWJHYLQJ x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
GRRUGHYHUJXQQLQJWHVSOLWVHQ x YHUJXQQLQJYRRUGHWHFKQLVFKHUHJHOVZDDUDDQHHQERXZZHUNPRHWYROGRHQ QXERXZEHVOXLW x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
'RRUWHZHUNHQPHWPHOGLQJHQNXQQHQDGPLQLVWUDWLHYHODVWHQYHUPLQGHUGZRUGHQ'DDUQDDVWLVHUHHQ WRHWVPRPHQWHQZRUGWLQIRUPDWLHEHVFKLNEDDUJHVWHOGDDQGHUGHQ ELMYRRUEHHOGEUDQGZHHU YHLOLJKHLGVUHJLR 2RNJHHIWKHWLQ]LFKWLQGHRPJHYLQJ$DQGDFKWVSXQWLVGDWHUFRQVHTXHQWLHVNXQQHQ]LMQ YRRUGHWRH]LFKWKRXGHQGHUROYDQGHJHPHHQWH
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
JHPHHQWHOLMNHYHURUGHQLQJHQ]LMQRSJHQRPHQ+HWRPJHYLQJVSODQLVGXVEUHGHUGDQ HHQEHVWHPPLQJVSODQ+HW5LMNNRPWQRJPHWHHQOLMVWGLHDDQJHHIWZHONHYHURUGHQLQJHQYHUSOLFKWZHONH IDFXOWDWLHIRIZHONHJHHQRQGHUGHHOYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQPRHWHQ]LMQ +HWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQPHWYHUEUHGHUHLNZLMGWHµ+RJH$NNHU6SHHOKHLGHHQ'H/HHXZHULN¶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
G
5HJHOVRSJHELHGVQLYHDXXLWJDQJVSXQW
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
JHYDOOHQLVHUVSUDNHYDQHHQIXQFWLHGLHYDQZHJHGHHLJHQEHODQJHQRIGHEHODQJHQYDQGHUGHQ JHGHWDLOOHHUGPRHWZRUGHQYDVWJHOHJG,QGLHJHYDOOHQLVKHWJRHGRPIXQFWLHVSHUFHHOVJHULFKWWRHWHGHOHQ .HX]H 3ODQYRUPLQJLVPDDWZHUN*HELHGVJHULFKWEHVWHPPHQLVKHWXLWJDQJVSXQWHQZRUGWWRHJHSDVWZDDUGLWNDQ SHUFHHOVJHULFKWZDDUKHWµPRHW¶
H
8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHWRHSDVVHQ
7RHOLFKWLQJ ,QGHPHPRULHYDQWRHOLFKWLQJYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHWVWDDWGDWHUEHKRHIWHLVDDQHHQQLHXZHYRUPYDQ JHELHGVRQWZLNNHOLQJGH]RJHQRHPGHµRUJDQLVFKHJHELHGVRQWZLNNHOLQJ¶+LHUELMJDDWKHWRPHHQDXWRQRPH RQWZLNNHOLQJGLHDDQVOXLWELMGHZHQVRPPLQGHULQµEODXZGUXNNHQYDQERYHQDI¶WHGHQNHQ+HWLQLWLDWLHI ZRUGWPHHUELMLQZRQHUVHQEHGULMYHQJHOHJG ,QGHKXLGLJHZHWJHYLQJZRUGWLQKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQEHSDDOGZHONHIXQFWLHVRSZHONHSOHNNHQ]LMQ WRHJHVWDDQ WRHODWLQJVSODQRORJLH ,QGH]HVLWXDWLHZRUGWKHWHLQGEHHOGYDVWJHOHJGLQGHYRUPYDQPHW QDPHJHGHWDLOOHHUGHEHVWHPPLQJVSODQQHQ'HUHGHQHQKLHUYRRU]LMQ x PLQGHUULVLFR¶VRSKRJHSODQVFKDGHV x PLQGHUFRPSOH[HRQGHU]RHNHQ RSEDVLVYDQZRUVWFDVHVFHQDULR x PHHUGXLGHOLMNKHLGHQUHFKWV]HNHUKHLGYRRUEHODQJKHEEHQGHQ 1DGHHOKLHUYDQLVGDWQLHWZRUGWJHDQWLFLSHHUGRSQRJQLHWYRRU]LHQHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQHQLQQRYDWLHV%LM JHZHQVWHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQPRHWGHJHKHOHSURFHGXUHGRRUORSHQZRUGHQ
'HQLHXZHZHWQHHPWGH]HEHOHPPHULQJHQGHHOVZHJRPPHHUPRJHOLMNKHGHQWHJHYHQYRRU µXLWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLH¶,QGHQLHXZHZHWZRUGWGHPRJHOLMNKHLGJHERGHQRP x SODQVFKDGHWHFODLPHQRSEDVLVYDQHHQYHUJXQQLQJHQQLHWRSEDVLVYDQHHQRPJHYLQJVSODQ x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µGRRUVFKXLYHQYDQRQGHU]RHNVODVWHQ¶ +LHUGRRUNDQWLMGHQJHOGEHVSDDUGZRUGHQHQZRUGW KHWRPJHYLQJVSODQPLQGHUXLWJHEUHLG'RRUGDWLQHHQ ODWHUVWDGLXPGHRQGHU]RHNHQZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUG NXQQHQGH]HDIJHVWHPGZRUGHQRSGHGDDGZHUNHOLMN WHUHDOLVHUHQVLWXDWLH'DDUQDDVWNXQQHQRPJHYLQJVSODQQHQIOH[LEHOHUZRUGHQLQJHULFKWHQLVKHWPDNNHOLMNHU RPXLWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHWRHWHSDVVHQ (HQDDQGDFKWVSXQWLVUHFKWV]HNHUKHLG'RRUGHRQGHU]RHNHQGRRUWHVFKXLYHQLVELMGHYDVWVWHOOLQJYDQKHW
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x :DW]LMQGHJHYROJHQYRRUKHWZDDUPDNHQYDQGHJHPHHQWHOLMNHDPELWLHV" x :DW]LMQGHJHYROJHQYRRUUHFKWV]HNHUKHLG" x :DW]LMQGHJHYROJHQYRRUGHLQLWLDWLHIQHPHU" J +HWPHQJSDQHHOWRHSDVVHQ 7RHOLFKWLQJ 1HGHUODQGLVWHGLYHUVYRRUHHQVWDQGDDUGDDQSDN'DDURPNDQVWUDNVZRUGHQJHZHUNWPHWHHQMXULGLVFK µPHQJSDQHHO¶'LWPHQJSDQHHOELHGWGHPRJHOLMNKHLGSHUJHELHGGHJHZHQVWHRIWRHODDWEDUH
NZDOLWHLWVQLYHDXVYDVWWHVWHOOHQYRRUYHUVFKLOOHQGHDVSHFWHQ]RDOVJHOXLGRIJHXU 'LWµPHQJSDQHHO¶YLVXDOLVHHUWGHPRJHOLMNKHGHQRP GHORNDOHRPJHYLQJVNZDOLWHLWYRUPWHJHYHQ9RRU GHPLOLHXDVSHFWHQOXFKWNZDOLWHLWHQH[WHUQH YHLOLJKHLG]LMQDOOHHQVWDQGDDUGZDDUGHQ RSJHQRPHQ(HQODJHUHQRUPGDQVWDQGDDUGPDJ ZHOPDDUKRJHUGDQVWDQGDDUGQLHW9RRUGH PLOLHXDVSHFWHQJHOXLGWULOOLQJJHXUHQERGHP]LMQ VWDQGDDUGZDDUGHQp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¶W=DQG :DQQHHUJHEUXLNJHPDDNWZRUGWYDQKHWPHQJSDQHHONDQKHWJRHG]LMQRPKLHURRNHHQSURJUDPPDDDQWH
NRSSHOHQ+LHULQZRUGWDDQJHJHYHQKRHGHVWUHQJHUHQRUPHQZRUGHQEHUHLNW'DDUQDDVWLVKHWGHEDVLVRP WHPRQLWRUHQ 9RRUGDWKHWµPHQJSDQHHO¶ZRUGWLQJH]HWZRUGWRQGHU]RFKWRIHUVSUDNHLVYDQUHJLRQDOH JHELHGVJHULFKWH DPELWLHV ELMYRRUEHHOGYRRUEHGULMYHQWHUUHLQHQ .HX]H :HSDVVHQKHWPHQJSDQHHOWRH+LHUELMZRUGWUHJLRQDOHDIVWHPPLQJJH]RFKWYRRU]RYHUKHWPLOLHXQRUPHQ EHWUHIWGLHHIIHFWHQRYHUGHJUHQ]HQYDQGHJHPHHQWHQKHHQ NXQQHQ KHEEHQ
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
/RVODWHQ
6WLPXOHUHQ
)DFLOLWHUHQ
5HJLVVHUHQ
2PVFKULMYLQJ 'HJHPHHQWHKHHIWJHHQUROLQ KHWSDUWLFLSDWLHWUDMHFW'H LQLWLDWLHIQHPHUJHHIWKHWWUDMHFW ]HOIYRUPHQYRHUWKHW SDUWLFLSDWLHWUDMHFWJHKHHO]HOI XLW
'HJHPHHQWHODDWGH XLWYRHULQJKLHUYDQELMGH LQLWLDWLHIQHPHU'H]HZRUGW GRRUGHJHPHHQWHRSZHJ JHKROSHQPHWHHQYRRUEHHOG HQIRUPDWV'HJHPHHQWH KHHIW]HOIJHHQDFWLHYHURO 'HJHPHHQWHKHHIWHHQ DGYLVHUHQGHUROULFKWLQJGH LQLWLDWLHIQHPHUHQERUJWGDWGH SDUWLFLSDWLHRSHHQJRHGH PDQLHUSODDWVYLQGW'H JHPHHQWHVWHOW UDQGYRRUZDDUGHQHQHLVHQ 'HJHPHHQWHQHHPWKHW SDUWLFLSDWLHWUDMHFWYROOHGLJRS ]LFK
9RRUGHOHQ x JHHQDPEWHOLMNH NRVWHQ x SDVWLQGHOLMQYDQ GHWHUXJWUHGHQGH RYHUKHLGHQKHW µRYHUODWHQ¶DDQGH VDPHQOHYLQJ
x
x x
x x
SDVWLQGHOLMQYDQGH WHUXJWUHGHQGH RYHUKHLGHQKHW µRYHUODWHQ¶DDQGH VDPHQOHYLQJ PLQGHUDPEWHOLMNH NRVWHQ GHNDQVLVJURWHUGDW SDUWLFLSDWLHRSHHQ MXLVWHZLM]HZRUGW XLWJHYRHUG'LW YHUJURRWGHNDQVRS GUDDJYODNHQGDDUPHH NRUWHUHSURFHGXUHV JHPHHQWHKRXGW YROOHGLJUHJLH GHNDQVLVJURWHUGDW SDUWLFLSDWLHRSHHQ MXLVWHZLM]HZRUGW XLWJHYRHUG'LW YHUJURRWGHNDQVRS GUDDJYODNHQGDDUPHH NRUWHUHSURFHGXUHV
x x
x x
x x
x x x
$DQGDFKWVSXQWHQ RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ]RQGHU LQYORHGRSGHRPJHYLQJ NRPHQYULMZHOQLHWYRRU NDQVJURRWGDW SDUWLFLSDWLHQLHWRS MXLVWHZLM]H]RUJYXOGLJ ZRUGWXLWJHYRHUG SURFHVVHQNXQQHQ ODQJHUGXUHQJHHQ GUDDJYODN NDQVJURRWGDW SDUWLFLSDWLHQLHWRS MXLVWHZLM]H]RUJYXOGLJ ZRUGWXLWJHYRHUG SURFHVVHQNXQQHQ ODQJHUGXUHQJHHQ GUDDJYODN KRJHDPEWHOLMNHNRVWHQ
KRJHDPEWHOLMNHNRVWHQ QLHWLQOLMQPHWGH KXLGLJHWHQGHQVYDQGH WHUXJWUHGHQGHRYHUKHLG ELMSDUWLFXOLHUH LQLWLDWLHYHQYHUVFKXLIW KHWHLJHQDDUVFKDSYDQ GHVDPHQOHYLQJQDDUGH RYHUKHLG
'HUROOHQYDQGHJHPHHQWHNXQQHQJHGXUHQGHKHWWUDMHFWYHUDQGHUHQHULVJHHQKDUGHVFKHLGVOLMQ 'DDUQDDVW]LMQHUYHUVFKLOOHQGHYRUPHQYDQSDUWLFLSDWLH 9RUPSDUWLFLSDWLH ,QIRUPHUHQ
5DDGSOHJHQ
$GYLVHUHQ
&RSURGXFHUHQ
0HH EHVOLVVHQ
=HOIEHKHHU
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
HQWHRQGHUKRXGHQ3ROLWLHNHQEHVWXXU]LMQKLHUQLHWELMEHWURNNHQ 5ROEHWURNNHQHQDXWRQRPHEHVOLVVHU
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
5ROUDDG±FROOHJH 'H2PJHYLQJVZHWNDQJHYROJHQKHEEHQYRRUGHUROYHUGHOLQJWXVVHQGHUDDGHQKHWFROOHJH,QGHZHWLV KLHUYRRUGHPRJHOLMNKHLGRSJHQRPHQRPGHOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQWHGHOHJHUHQDDQKHWFROOHJHRIKHW YRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLW D 'HOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQGHOHJHUHQ 7RHOLFKWLQJ 'HJHPHHQWHUDDGNDQGHEHYRHJGKHLGWRWKHWYDVWVWHOOHQYDQGHOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQGHOHJHUHQDDQ KHWFROOHJH+HWGHOHJDWLHEHVOXLWYRUPWHHQDI]RQGHUOLMNEHVOXLWGDWJHHQGHHOXLWPDDNWYDQKHW RPJHYLQJVSODQ+HWGHOHJDWLHEHVOXLWJHHIWGHUHLNZLMGWHYDQGHEHYRHJGKHLG+HWEHSDDOWELQQHQZHONH JUHQ]HQHQRQGHUZHONHYRRUZDDUGHQGHEHYRHJGKHLGNDQRIPRHWZRUGHQXLWJHRHIHQG2RNNDQLQKHW GHOHJDWLHEHVOXLWEHSDDOGZRUGHQKRHKHWFROOHJHXLWYRHULQJPRHWJHYHQDDQGHJHGHOHJHHUGHEHYRHJGKHLG 'HPRJHOLMNKHLGRPGHOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQWHGHOHJHUHQELHGWUXLPWHYRRUWRHGHOLQJYDQ EHYRHJGKHGHQRSPDDW0HWGHOHJDWLHNDQGHUDDGHUYRRU]RUJHQGDWGHXLWYRHULQJYDQKHWEHOHLGELMKHW XLWYRHUHQGHRUJDDQQHHUJHOHJGZRUGW2RNYDQXLWKHWRRJSXQWYDQHIILFLHQF\HQIOH[LELOLWHLWNDQGHOHJDWLH ZHQVHOLMN]LMQ 9RRUXLWORSHQGRSKHWZHUNHQPHWKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ]LMQEHSDDOGHPRJHOLMNKHGHQYRRUGHOHJDWLHGHQNEDDU 'HOHJDWLHYDQKHWYHUWDOHQYDQYHUOHHQGHRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJHQLQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ
:DDUVFKLMQOLMNZRUGHQRQWZLNNHOLQJHQLQGHWRHNRPVWVWHHGVYDNHUPHWHHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJPRJHOLMN JHPDDNW'LWNDQVWUDNVRRNQRJVWHHGVLQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ+HWYHUOHQHQYDQHHQ RPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJLVHHQVQHOOHSURFHGXUHYDQZHNHQRRNLQKHWJHYDOGDWVSUDNHLVYDQDIZLMNLQJYDQ KHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ'H2PJHYLQJVZHWEHSDDOWGDWGHJHPHHQWHUDDGYHUJXQQLQJHQYRRUDIZLMNDFWLYLWHLWHQ ELQQHQYLMIMDDUPRHWYHUZHUNHQLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ'HUDDGVWXXUWRSKRRIGOLMQHQHQKHWYHUWDOHQYDQ YHUOHHQGHRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJHQLVHHQDGPLQLVWUDWLHYHKDQGHOLQJ'DDURPOHHQWGLW]LFKJRHGYRRU GHOHJDWLH 'HOHJDWLHYDQKHWYHUWDOHQYDQEHOHLGVUHJHOVYDQUDDGHQFROOHJHLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ :DQQHHUGHUDDGRIKHWFROOHJHEHOHLGVUHJHOVKHEEHQYDVWJHVWHOGGLHGRRUYHUWDOLQJLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ EHKRHYHQNDQGLWGRRUKHWFROOHJHJHEHXUHQ+HWJDDWLPPHUVRPKHWYHUWDOHQYDQEHOHLGZDDUDOVSUDNHLV JHZHHVWYDQHHQLQKRXGHOLMNHDIZHJLQJ(HQGHUJHOLMNHDDQSDVVLQJYDQGHOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQLVDDQ WHPHUNHQDOVXLWYRHULQJHQGDDUPHHOLJWGHOHJDWLHDDQKHWFROOHJHYRRUGHKDQG 'HOHJDWLHELMQLHXZHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQ 2QWZLNNHOLQJHQGLHQLHWSDVVHQELQQHQHHQRPJHYLQJVSODQNXQQHQVWUDNVPRJHOLMNJHPDDNWZRUGHQPHW HHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJLQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQRIKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQNDQZRUGHQ
DDQJHSDVW2SGLWPRPHQWNDQGLWRRN'HEHYRHJGKHLGRPKHWEHVWHPPLQJVSODQDDQWHSDVVHQOLJWQXELM GHUDDG9DDNZRUGHQRQWZLNNHOLQJHQPRJHOLMNJHPDDNWPHWHHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJLQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHW EHVWHPPLQJVSODQ,QGLHJHYDOOHQEHSDDOWGH:HWUXLPWHOLMNHRUGHQLQJGDWGHUDDGKLHUYRRUHHQYHUNODULQJ YDQJHHQEHGHQNLQJHQDIJHHIW'RRUGHUDDG]LMQFDWHJRULHsQYDQJHYDOOHQEHQRHPGZDDUGH]HYHUNODULQJ YDQJHHQEHGHQNLQJHQYRRUJHOGW ]LHELMODJH 'H]HFDWHJRULHLQGHOLQJELHGWHHQJRHGHEDVLVYRRUGHOHJDWLHELMQLHXZHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQ 'HOHJDWLHYDQGHXLWZHUNLQJYDQ GHOHQYDQ GHRPJHYLQJVYLVLHLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ 9RRUKHWRSVWHOOHQYDQHHQRPJHYLQJVSODQVWHOWGHJHPHHQWHUDDGNDGHUV'LWJHEHXUWYLDHHQ RPJHYLQJVYLVLH2PGDWGLHHUQXQRJQLHWLVLVKHWRSGLWPRPHQWQLHWWHRQGHUERXZHQRSZHONH RQGHUGHOHQGHOHJDWLHYDQGHOHQYDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQDDQGHRUGHNDQ]LMQYRRUGHGRRUYHUWDOLQJYDQGH RPJHYLQJVYLVLH
.HX]H 1DLQZHUNLQJWUHGLQJYDQGH2PJHYLQJVZHWYRRUGHYROJHQGHJHYDOOHQHHQGHOHJDWLHEHVOXLWQHPHQ 'HOHJDWLHYDQKHWYHUWDOHQYDQYHUOHHQGHRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJHQLQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHW RPJHYLQJVSODQ 'HOHJDWLHYDQKHWYHUWDOHQYDQEHOHLGVUHJHOVYDQUDDGHQFROOHJHLQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ 'HOHJDWLHELMQLHXZHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQLQOLMQPHWEHVWDDQGHFDWHJRULHLQGHOLQJELMGHYHUNODULQJYDQ JHHQEHGHQNLQJHQ 'DDUQDDVW %LMYDVWVWHOOLQJYDQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLHVSHFLILHNDDQGDFKWEHVWHGHQDDQGHPRJHOLMNKHLGRPGHOHQ YDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQWHGHOHJHUHQDDQKHWFROOHJH E 9RRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWGHOHJHUHQ 7RHOLFKWLQJ +HWYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWLVHHQEHVOXLWGDWWLMGHOLMNRQWZLNNHOLQJHQLQSHUNWGLHRSJURQGYDQGHJHOGHQGH UHJHOVPRJHOLMN]LMQ+HWNDQELMYRRUEHHOGGDWLHWVLVWRHJHVWDDQYROJHQVKHWKXLGLJHEHVWHPPLQJVSODQPDDU QLHWYROJHQVKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQLQYRRUEHUHLGLQJ'HJHPHHQWHUDDGNDQGDQHHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLW QHPHQZDDUGRRUUHJHOVWLMGHOLMNQLHWJHOGHQ 'HEHYRHJGKHLGWRWKHWQHPHQYDQHHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWNDQZRUGHQJHGHOHJHHUGDDQKHWFROOHJH 'H]HPRJHOLMNKHLGEHVWDDWRQGHUGH:HWUXLPWHOLMNHRUGHQLQJQLHW,QGHQLHXZHZHWLVGLWRSJHQRPHQ RPGDWKHWFROOHJHHHQRPJHYLQJVSODQYRRUEHUHLGWHQGDDUPHHGDQRRNJRHGLQVWDDWLVRPRSHHQ HIIHFWLHYHZLM]HHHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWWHQHPHQ
(UZRUGWWRWRSKHGHQHLJHQOLMNQRRLWJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQGHPRJHOLMNKHLGRPHHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWWH QHPHQ0RJHOLMNZRUGWGLWDQGHUVRPGDWKHWLQGHQLHXZH2PJHYLQJVZHWDQGHUVYRUPZRUGWJHJHYHQ +HWYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWZLM]LJWKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ'HYRRUEHVFKHUPLQJVUHJHOVVWDDQVWUDNVQLHWPHHULQ KHWYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWPDDULQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ'HEXUJHUUDDGSOHHJWVOHFKWVppQGRFXPHQWKHW RPJHYLQJVSODQ'HYRRUEHVFKHUPLQJVUHJHOVNXQQHQQLHXZHUHJHOVDDQKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQWRHYRHJHQ'HQN GDDUELMDDQHHQYHUERGRSKHWUHDOLVHUHQYDQHHQDFWLYLWHLWRIHHQYHUERG]RQGHUYHUJXQQLQJHHQDFWLYLWHLW WHUHDOLVHUHQ'HYRRUEHVFKHUPLQJVUHJHOVNXQQHQRRNUHJHOVXLWKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQEXLWHQZHUNLQJVWHOOHQ (HQEHODQJULMNHUDQGYRRUZDDUGHLVGDWYRRUEHVFKHUPLQJVUHJHOVDOOHHQEHSHUNLQJHQPRJHQRSOHJJHQDDQ DFWLYLWHLWHQGLHZHO]LMQWRHJHODWHQRSJURQGYDQHHQRPJHYLQJVSODQPDDUGLHQRJQLHWSODDWVYLQGHQ+HW JHYROJKLHUYDQLVGDWHHQYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWEHVWDDQGJHEUXLNHQEHVWDDQGHERXZZHUNHQPRHW HHUELHGLJHQ,QIHLWHNXQQHQGHYRRUEHVFKHUPLQJVUHJHOVDOOHHQGHEHVWDDQGHVLWXDWLHEHYULH]HQ .HX]H (HQEHVOXLWQHPHQYRRUGHOHJDWLHYDQKHWYRRUEHUHLGLQJVEHVOXLWDDQKHWFROOHJHQDGDWGH2PJHYLQJVZHWLQ ZHUNLQJLVJHWUHGHQ:DQQHHUKHWLQVWUXPHQWYRRUGHHHUVWHNHHULVWRHJHSDVWGLHQWJHsYDOXHHUGWH
ZRUGHQ%HRRUGHHOGZRUGWRIKHWGHOHJDWLHEHVOXLWLQVWDQGNDQEOLMYHQ
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
,QVRPPLJHJHYDOOHQLVGLWHFKWHUQLHWYROGRHQGH+HWLVGDDURPJRHGRPGHFRPPLVVLHQDDVWGHZHWWHOLMNH WDNHQRRNWHODWHQDGYLVHUHQRYHUGHJHPHHQWHOLMNHHQSRWHQWLHHOJHPHHQWHOLMNHPRQXPHQWHQ'DDUQDDVW GLHQWSHUZLMNLQRYHUOHJPHWGHLQZRQHUVYDQGHEHWUHIIHQGHZLMNEHRRUGHHOGWHZRUGHQRIHHQDGYLHVRYHU DUFKLWHFWXXU YRRUKHHQZHOVWDQGVWRHWV HHQWRHJHYRHJGHZDDUGHKHHIW,QGLHJHYDOOHQZDDUHHQDGYLHV WRHJHYRHJGHZDDUGHKHHIWYRRUGHLQZRQHUVPRHWGHFRPPLVVLHRRNHHQURONULMJHQ .HX]H (HQRQDIKDQNHOLMNHFRPPLVVLHLQVWHOOHQYRRUGHZHWWHOLMNYHUSOLFKWHDFWLYLWHLWHQYRRUPRQXPHQWHQ]RUJHQ GDDUQDDVWYRRUDGYLVHULQJELMJHPHHQWHOLMNHHQSRWHQWLs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
.HX]H 'HVWUXFWXXUYDQGHEHJURWLQJDDQSDVVHQ]RGDWGH]HDDQVOXLWELMGH2PJHYLQJVZHW
F $DQVOXLWHQELMKHW'LJLWDDO6WHOVHO2PJHYLQJVZHW '62 7RHOLFKWLQJ 2PGHYHUEHWHULQJHQYDQGHZHWWHUHDOLVHUHQLVRQGHUVWHXQHQGHGLJLWDOLVHULQJEHODQJULMN+HW'62GLHQW PHWQDPHKHWJHEUXLNVJHPDNKHWLQ]LFKWLQKHWRPJHYLQJVUHFKWHQEHWHUHHQVQHOOHUHEHVOXLWYRUPLQJ0HW KHW'62NULMJWGHJHEUXLNHUppQGLJLWDDOORNHW9LDKHWORNHWKHEEHQLQZRQHUVEHGULMYHQHQRYHUKHGHQppQ JHEUXLNVYULHQGHOLMNHWRHJDQJWRWGHUHOHYDQWHJHJHYHQVRYHUGH NZDOLWHLWYDQGH I\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJHQ WRWRPJHYLQJVGRFXPHQWHQ*HEUXLNHUVNULMJHQ]RVQHOOHULQ]LFKWLQZDWZHORIQLHWPDJRSHHQORFDWLHHQRI HHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJRIPHOGLQJYHUHLVWLV*HEUXLNHUVNXQQHQLQppQPRHLWHGRRURRNDDQYUDJHQYRRU RPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJHQHQPHOGLQJHQLQGLHQHQ +HW'62EHVWDDWEHKDOYHXLWGLH]RJHQRHPGHODQGHOLMNHYRRU]LHQLQJQRJXLWHHQWZHHGHQRRG]DNHOLMN RQGHUGHHOQDPHOLMNHHQµUHJLVWHURPJHYLQJVGRFXPHQWHQ¶'HJHPHHQWHNDQKDDUV\VWHPHQRRNNRSSHOHQ DDQ RQGHUGHOHQYDQ GHODQGHOLMNHYRRU]LHQLQJ +HW'62ZRUGWLQIDVHQRQWZLNNHOGGRRUKHW5LMN'HGRRUORRSWLMGRPWRWHHQDIJHURQG'62WHNRPHQLV JHSODQGWRW:HNXQQHQHUYRRUNLH]HQRPDOVJHPHHQWHQXDOYDVWDFWLHIDDQGHVODJWHJDDQPHWGH DDQVOXLWLQJRSGLW'62HQNRSORSHUWH]LMQ:HNXQQHQRRNZDFKWHQWRWHUPHHUEHNHQGLVHQGDQ DDQVOXLWHQ
,QGHYLVLH,QIRUPDWLVHULQJHQ$XWRPDWLVHULQJLVGHNRHUVXLWJH]HWYRRUGHLQ]HWYDQ LQIRUPDWLHYRRU]LHQLQJHQDXWRPDWLVHULQJYRRUGHJHPHHQWH,QGHYLVLH]HWGHJHPHHQWHGHDPELWLHQHHU RPRSKHWJHELHGYDQ, $µVOLPPHYROJHU¶WH]LMQ8LWJDQJVSXQWGDDUELMLVVOLPWRHSDVVHQYDQZDW]LFK HOGHUVKHHIWEHZH]HQ .HX]H 'HDPELWLHXLWGHYLVLH,QIRUPDWLVHULQJHQ$XWRPDWLVHULQJRPµVOLPPHYROJHU¶WH]LMQZRUGWRRNWHQ DDQ]LHQYDQKHWDDQVOXLWHQRSKHW'62JHYROJG
%LMODJH7KHPDVHVVLHFROOHJHVHQUDGHQ
(HUVWHWKHPDVHVVLH 2QGHUZHUS ,QYRHULQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ
.ZDOLWHLWI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJ
5ROYHUGHOLQJFROOHJH UDDG
5ROYDQGHJHPHHQWHLQGHVDPHQOHYLQJ
7ZHHGHWKHPDVHVVLH 2QGHUZHUS *H]RQGKHLGRQGHUGH2PJHYLQJVZHW
/RVODWHQYDQUHJHOV
8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLH
0HQJSDQHHO
'HUGHWKHPDVHVVLH 2QGHUZHUS 3DUWLFLSDWLHELMGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH
3DUWLFLSDWLHELMKHWRPJHYLQJVSODQ
5RGHGUDDG x H[WHUQHIRFXV x YHUQLHXZHQGLQVWHNHQ x OHIWRQHQ x NDQVHQJULMSHQPDDUQLHWZHJJRRLHQZDWJRHGJDDW x DPELWLHXLWZHUNHQLQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLH x PRHLOLMNSULRULWHULQJDDQWHEUHQJHQ x MHWKXLVYRHOHQ x MHYHLOLJYRHOHQLQMHRPJHYLQJ x ORVODWHQPDDUQLHWWHQNRVWHYDQGHUROYDQGHUDDG x GHOHJDWLHPHWGXLGHOLMNHNDGHUV x SDUWLFLSDWLHPRHWJHERUJGZRUGHQ x RSWKHPD¶V]RDOVEHUHLNEDDUKHLGYHLOLJKHLG ZRQLQJERXZSURJUDPPHULQJHQFXOWXXUKLVWRULHPRHWGH JHPHHQWHUHJLHEOLMYHQYRHUHQ x ZDDUPRJHOLMNVWLPXOHUHQHLJHQYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHLG LQLWLDWLHIQHPHU x SHUJHELHGPDDWZHUNWHQDDQ]LHQYDQGHUROYDQGH JHPHHQWH
5RGHGUDDG x HU]LMQYDQXLWJH]RQGKHLGYHUELQGLQJHQWHPDNHQ WXVVHQKHWUXLPWHOLMNHHQKHWVRFLDOHGRPHLQ x JH]RQGKHLGLVVXEMHFWLHI x PDDWZHUNSHUVLWXDWLH x EDODQV]RHNHQWXVVHQORVODWHQHQUHFKWVEHVFKHUPLQJ x YRRUDIJRHGHDIVSUDNHQPDNHQRYHUGH XLWJDQJVSXQWHQLVHVVHQWLHHO x LQVRPPLJHJHELHGHQZLOMHORVODWHQHQLQVRPPLJH JHELHGHQMXLVWQLHW x NLMNHQQDDUKHWHIIHFWYDQGHUHJHOLVEHODQJULMN x 5HGHQHUHQYDQXLWKHWGRHOYDQGHUHJHO x 8LWQRGLJLQJVSODQRORJLHKHHIWGHYRRUNHXUPDDUZHOPHW JRHGHNDGHUVRSEDVLVYDQHHQJRHGHYLVLH x %HVFKHUPHQYDQGHRPJHYLQJLVZHOEHODQJULMN x (QHUJLHVWHNHQLQHHQJRHGHSDUWLFLSDWLH x *RHGHPRJHOLMNKHLGYRRUKHWDDQEUHQJHQYDQ GLIIHUHQWLDWLHV x $IVWHPPHQPHWEXXUJHPHHQWHQLVYDQEHODQJ
5RGHGUDDG x 2QGDQNVKHWDEVWUDFWHQLYHDXYDQGHRPJHYLQJVYLVLHLV KHWEHODQJULMNGDWEXUJHUVEHWURNNHQZRUGHQ x +HWDEVWUDFWHQLYHDXYUDDJWRPHHQDQGHUHPDQLHUYDQ FRPPXQLFHUHQ x 'HVDPHQOHYLQJ]DOJHSULNNHOGPRHWHQZRUGHQRPPHHWH GHQNHQ x +HWGRHOYDQSDUWLFLSDWLHPRHWYRRUDIKHOGHU]LMQ x +HOGHUPRHW]LMQZLHZHONHUROVSHHOW
x
3DUWLFLSDWLHELMHHQRPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJ
x x x x
9HUZDFKWLQJHQYDQGHSDUWLFLSDWLHLQEHHOGNULMJHQYDQGH GHHOQHPHUVHQRSHONDDUDIVWHPPHQ 'HUDDGPRHWKHWSURFHVPRQLWRUHQ *HPHHQWHHQEHZRQHUVPRHWHQGLFKWHUELMHONDDUNRPHQ ,QVWHHNPRHWQLHW]LMQGDWLHGHUHHQDNNRRUGPRHWJDDQ 'HEXUHQEHQDGHUHQEHWHNHQWGDWMHHONDDUVHULHXVQHHPW
%LMODJH%HOHLGRPJHYLQJVYLVLH
%HOHLG
$FWXHHO"
0LVWHULHWVLQKHW GRFXPHQW"
,VHULHWVQLHW PHHUQRGLJ"
:HUNEDDU"$OWLMG WRHSDVVHQRIYDDN DIZLMNHQ"
2SQHPHQLQ LQWHJUDOH RPJHYLQJV YLVLH"
$UFKHRORJLHHQ FXOWXXUKLVWRULH
DUFKHRORJLHEHOHLG
:RUGWPRPHQWHHO JHDFWXDOLVHHUG
-D
%RGHP
%RGHPEHKHHUSODQERGHPNZDOLWHLWVNDDUW
-D
(ULVQRJJHHQEHOHLG YRRU:.2LQ RSJHQRPHQ
1HH
$OWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-D
:HOVWDQG
1RWD:HOVWDQGPHWEHOHLGHQGDDURS JHEDVHHUGHEHOHLGVUHJHOVYRRUDFWXHOH RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ%HHOGNZDOLWHLWVNDGHU %XLWHQJHELHG
+HW %HHOGNZDOLWHLWVNDGHU EXLWHQJHELHGWH DFWXDOLVHUHQRSEDVLV YDQGHUHFHQWH 6WUXFWXXUYLVLH EXLWHQJHELHG
'DWKDQJWYDQGH DPELWLHYDQGHUDDG DI
%HOHLGVQRWLWLHPDQWHO]RUJZRQLQJHQ %HOHLGVQRWLWLHEHGULMIVZRQLQJHQRS EHGULMYHQWHUUHLQHQ %HOHLGVQRWLWLHWLMGHOLMNHZRRQHHQKHLGRS ERXZORFDWLH
$FWXDOLVHUHQ
-DDOOHDDQYUDJHQ RPJHYLQJVYHUJXQQLQJ YRRUSHUPDQHQWHERXZ ZRUGHQDDQGH VWDGVERXZPHHVWHU YRRUJHOHJGWHU EHRRUGHOLQJYDQKHW ZHOVWDQGVDVSHFW :HWRHWVHQHUDDQ
-D
%RXZHQHQJHEUXLN
'HZHOVWDQGV FRPSRQHQWHQXLWKHW %HHOGNZDOLWHLWVSODQ EHGULMYHQWHUUHLQHQ PRHWHQQRJPHWHHQ EHOHLGVUHJHOZRUGHQ JHFRPSHQVHHUG -D
'XXU]DDPKHLG
%HOHLGVSODQ(QHUJLHHQ0DWHULDDOWUDQVLWLH MD XLWYRHULQJVSURJUDPPDHQHUJLHWUDQVLWLH 5DDGVEHVOXLW GRVVLHU /DDGSDOHQEHOHLG QRJYDVWWHVWHOOHQ 1RWDGXXU]DDPZRQHQ QRJYDVWWHVWHOOHQ 1RWDERPHQYHUVXV]RQQHSDQHOHQ
QHH
1HH
:HWRHWVHQDDQKHWKDOHQ $OOHHQGH YDQGHDPELWLHV UHOHYDQWH DVSHFWHQ
(FRQRPLVFKH]DNHQ
EHOHLGVQRWLWLH'HWDLOKDQGHO EHGULMYHQWHUUHLQHQYLVLH QRWDEHKHHUVUHJHOLQJOHHJVWDDQGH EHGULMIVJHERXZHQ ++ XLWJDQJVSXQWHQFRPPHUFLsOHYRRU]LHQLQJHQ LQFHQWUXPRQWZLNNHOLQJ UHJLRQDOHDIVSUDNHQZHUNORFDWLHV 6*(
-D
%HGULMYHQWHUUHLQHQYLVLH
:HUNEDDU
-D
'LHQVWYHUOHQLQJ
9LVLH'LHQVWYHUOHQLQJ%HVW *UDDJHQRS PDDW
MD
HULVQRJJHHQ XLWZHUNLQJVSODQ
7RHSDVVHQ
1HH
-DHU]LMQJHQRHJ UHJHOLQJHQGLHZHJ NXQQHQ
-D
*HXU
9HURUGHQLQJHQJHELHGVYLVLHJHXUKLQGHUHQ YHHKRXGHULMJHPHHQWH%HVW
-D
1HH
$OWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-D
*HOXLGELM HYHQHPHQWHQ
+RUHFDHQHYHQHPHQWHQEHOHLGVSODQ $TXDEHVWEHOHLG
1HH EHLGHKHU]LHQ
-D
1HH
-DDOWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-D
*HOXLG
2QWKHIILQJHQEHOHLGKRJHUHZDDUGHQ SURFHGXUH DDQYXOOLQJQRJYDVWWHVWHOOHQ $FWLHSODQRPJHYLQJVODZDDLLQFO JHOXLGVEHODVWLQJVNDDUWHQ =RQHEHKHHUSODQ
-D
1HH
2QWKHIILQJHQEHOHLG NDQNRPHQWH YHUYDOOHQ
-DDOWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-D
*URHQHQODQGVFKDS
*URHQEHOHLGVSODQ 1RWLWLHERPHQYHUVXV]RQQHSDQHOHQ
-D
1HH
1HH
-DDOWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-D
%HOHLGVSODQWRH]LFKWHQKDQGKDYHQ 'HHOVDFWXHHOHQGHHOV 'LW]LMQGHUHOHYDQWH QLHWPHHUDFWXHHO EHOHLGVVWXNNHQYRRU JHPHHQWHQ%HVWHQ 9HOGKRYHQ +DQGKDYLQJ /DQGHOLMNHKDQGKDYLQJVVWUDWHJLH +DQGUHLNLQJEHVWXXUOLMNH VDQFWLHPLGGHOHQ +DQGKDYLQJVEHOHLGDXWRKDQGHOV +DQGKDYLQJUXLPWHOLMNHUHJHOJHYLQJ %HOHLGVUHJHOVJHGRJHQ 0LOLHXKDQGKDYLQJ %HOHLGZRQLQJRQWUXLPLQJHQ 'DPRFOHVEHOHLG 'HILQLWLHYHULVLFRDQDO\VH%HVW9HOGKRYHQ %HOHLGVUHJHOVWRHSDVVLQJ:HW%,%2% ,QWHJUDDO9HLOLJKHLGVSODQ'H.HPSHQ 9DVWJRHGEHKHHU
1HH
-DDOWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-DRYHUKHW DOJHPHHQZHO
,QVSUDDNSDUWLFLSDWLH RPJHYLQJVGLDORRJ
-D
-DFRQFUHWHULFKWOLMQHQ YRRUSDUWLFLSDWLH
1HH
(ONHVLWXDWLHLVDQGHUVHQ YUDDJWRPPDDWZHUN'LW LVZHUNEDDUPDDUHU]LMQ GDDUYRRUZHOJRHGHHQ KHOGHUHULFKWOLMQHQQRGLJ
1HH
.DEHOVHQOHLGLQJHQ RSHQEDUHYHUOLFKWLQJ
-D
1HH
1HH
9ROGRHQGH
7H]LMQHUWLMG JHDFWXDOLVHHUG EHOHLGRSQHPHQ 2SHQEDUH YHUOLFKWLQJ PHHQHPHQ
+DQGKDYLQJ
x x x x x x x x x x x x x
+DQGERHN.DEHOVHQ/HLGLQJHQ 5DDGVEHVOXLW9HURUGHQLQJRQGHUJURQGVH LQIUDVWUXFWXXU %HOHLGVSODQRSHQEDUHYHUOLFKWLQJ
/XFKWKDYHQ
/XFKWKDYHQEHVOXLW9RJHOEHKHHUVJHELHG 5DGDUYHUVWRULQJVJHELHGHQ 0XQLWLH]RQHULQJ ,/6YHUVWRULQJVJHELHG *URQGJHERQGHQJHOXLG )XQQHOHQ,+&6 *HOXLGV]RQHV.H]RQHULQJ %HSHUNLQJHQJHELHG
/XFKWNZDOLWHLW
/XFKWNZDOLWHLWVSODQ -D 8LWYRHULQJVSURJUDPPD/XFKW LQFOEHOHLGJHYRHOLJHREMHFWHQ OXFKWNZDOLWHLW 0LOLHXEHOHLGVSODQLQFOEHVWXXUOLMNHXLWVSUDDN 1HH WRHSDVVHQWRWLQZHUNLQJWUHGLQJ 2PJHYLQJVZHW
1HH
1HH
$OWLMGWRHSDVVHQ
-DJH]RQGKHLG
'HIXQFWLHYDQKHW PLOLHXEHOHLGVSODQ ZRUGWRYHUJHQRPHQ GRRUGH RPJHYLQJVYLVLH
$OOHHQ EHOHLGVSODQ JHYRHOLJH REMHFWHQ $PELWLHVYRRUGH PLOLHXWKHPD¶V ZRUGHQRSQLHXZ EHSDDOGYRRUGH RPJHYLQJVYLVLH
5XLPWHOLMNHSODQQHQ
6WUXFWXXUYLVLH
1HH
-DDFWXDOLWHLW
1HH
:HLQLJFRQFUHWHNDGHUV
-D
5XLPWHOLMNHSODQQHQ
'HHOV
'HHOV
-D
-D
1HH
0RJHOLMNHQNHOHURGH NQRSHQ 1HH
-D
5XLPWHOLMNHSODQQHQ
6WUXFWXXUYLVLHJURHQHPDQWHOPHWURGH NQRSHQ 6WUXFWXXUYLVLH%XLWHQJHELHG
-DDDQGDFKWVSXQWHQ
-D
5XLPWHOLMNHSODQQHQ
/DQGVFKDSVLQYHVWHULQJVUHJHOLQJ
1HH
0HHUPDDWZHUNQRGLJ YRRUVSHFLILHNHJHYDOOHQ
-D
5XLPWHOLMNHSODQQHQ