CConstaterende datBergen op Zoom
Koppel je AI →
Document · PDF

103. Mail Nakad Law inzake Staatsontvoeringen in Nederland geanonimiseerd. Behandelvoorstel: in handen gesteld college ter afdoening.

Commissie (Algemeen) 14 april 2022, gemeente Bergen op ZoomBij agendapunt: Mededelingen/ingekomen post gerelateerd aan de Algemene Commissie26.893 woorden

Open het PDF bij de gemeente ↗Naar de vergadering →

Tekst van het document

Uit het bestand gehaald, zonder opmaak, tabellen en afbeeldingen · deel 1 van 3

Aan: Raadsgriffies van de Nederlandse Gemeenten To: The Clerks of the Dutch Municipalities Cc: Het bestuur van de Vereniging Nederlandse Gemeenten CC

Good leaders inspire people to have confidence in their leader. Great leaders inspire people to have confidence in themselves.” ~Eleanor Roosevelt

Amstelveen, 8 april 2022 | 8 April 2022

Geachte raadsgriffier, English translation below 1. Hoewel jeugdzorg is bedoeld voor “bescherming”, “zorg” en “hulp” veroorzaakt zij in Nederland al tientallen jaren veel menselijk leed, en biedt zij weinig tot geen bescherming, zorg en hulp. Vanwege de enorme omvang van deze publiek-private miljardenindustrie, is een humanitaire ramp van ongekende omvang ontstaan. Verreweg de meeste kinderen in de jeugdzorg zijn slachtoffer van onrechtmatige

uithuisplaatsingen, “Staatsontvoeringen”[1], en daarmee slachtoffer van mensenhandel/exploitatie/moderne slavernij (OTS/UHP). Er zijn 450.000-900.000 kinderen slachtoffer van onrechtmatige staatsbemoeienis en daarmee eveneens van mensenhandel/exploitatie/moderne slavernij (OTS). Toch groeit de jeugdzorgindustrie ongehinderd door. Feitelijk is de Nederlandse jeugdzorg geen onderdeel meer van de rechtsstaat, maar is sprake van georganiseerde misdaad, verweven met het openbaar bestuur (maffia). 2. Doordat sprake is van een bewuste wijdverbreide, stelselmatige aanval gericht tegen de Nederlandse burgerbevolking (mannen, vrouwen en kinderen), kwalificeren deze mensenrechtenschendingen als misdaden tegen de menselijkheid; deze verjaren niet. Deze misdaden worden sinds 2015 gepleegd in naam van de gemeente. Het College van B&W vormt het dagelijks bestuur, ambtenaren zijn betrokken, en de gemeenteraad is het hoogste orgaan dat de rechtmatigheid moet controleren. Individuele gemeenteraadsleden zijn daarom persoonlijk verantwoordelijk en aansprakelijk. Ik verzoek u daarom met klem ervoor zorg te dragen dat alle leden van de gemeenteraad, van het College van B&W en de betrokken ambtenaren dit mailbericht met bijlagen ontvangen.. 3.

Dit document bevat een formele analyse aan de hand van wetten en verdragen over de (on)rechtmatigheid en onrechtstatelijkheid van de Nederlandse jeugdzorg (hoofdstuk 3 – 5). De uitkomsten zijn schokkend, omdat hierdoor wordt aangetoond dat de ketenpartners opereren als een misdaadsyndicaat, en dat het openbaar bestuur en de rechterlijke macht zijn vermengd met georganiseerde misdaad. De analyse wijst uit dat (vrijwel) elke getroffen kinderbeschermingsmaatregel sinds 2015 nietig, onrechtstatelijk, onwettig (illegaal) en/of onrechtmatig is. Deze formele bevindingen staan los van eventuele toekomstige bevindingen (van toetsingscommissies) in het kader van de materiële toetsing op individueel dossierniveau. Hoewel die exercities nuttig zijn, kunnen we niet meer op de uitkomsten gaan wachten. 4. Dit document is niet alleen bedoeld voor gemeenteraadsleden, het College van B&W, gemeentelijke ambtenaren en de formateurs die nu in onderhandeling zijn na de verkiezingen van 16 maart 2022.

Het advies is ook bestemd voor elke jurist, elk bestuurslid en elke leidinggevende van een GI, elk fractie van de Eerste of Tweede Kamer der Staten-Generaal, elke Minister, elke beleidsambtenaar van het Ministerie van Justitie en Veiligheid, elke jeugdbeschermer van een GI die aan beroepsstandaarden moet voldoen, elke raadsonderzoeker van de Raad voor de Kinderbescherming, elke hoogleraar en elke lector van universiteiten en hogescholen, elke advocaat en elke rechter, elke pleegouder, elke gezinshuisouder en elke zzp’er, werknemer of organisatie in de jeugdzorgketen. 5. Nederland is op papier een rechtsstaat, maar de uitvoeringspraktijk van jeugdzorg is dat niet. Alle idealen over “naar 0 uithuisplaatsingen” blijven illusoir zolang de vermenging van georganiseerde misdaad met het openbaar bestuur en de rechtspraak niet wordt opgeheven: voor de komende vier jaar is opnieuw een verdubbeling van de groei van jeugdzorg voorzienbaar. De gemeenten mogen in de geschetste omstandigheden niet meer afgaan op een rechterlijke beschikking. U bent met dit advies, wat een vervolg is op eerdere stukken – laatstelijk mijn brief van 28 januari 2022 – op de hoogte, voor zover u als professional of bestuurder deze wettelijke bepalingen en verdragsbepalingen al niet kende, of behoorde te kennen. 6.

Schuift u uw gevoelens en uw geweten daarom niet langer opzij, maar doet u wat nodig is: recht doen aan de slachtoffers en voorkómen van nieuwe slachtoffers. De gemeenten hebben de sleutel in handen om deze inhumane en barbaarse commerciële praktijk te stoppen. De eerste concrete stap is de financiering te beëindigen en te zorgen dat de kinderen kunnen terugkeren naar huis. De kinderen die zonder wettelijke grondslag, illegaal, of onrechtmatig, onder Staatstoezicht zijn geplaatst, dienen ook daaruit te worden ontslagen. Door middel van aangepast beleid kunnen – en moeten – gemeenten nieuwe mensenrechtenschendingen voorkómen. 7. Mocht u vragen hebben, of concrete hulp willen voor uw gemeente of organisatie, dan ben ik uiteraard beschikbaar.

---------------------------------------

Dear clerk of the Municipal Council, [1] https://www.ad.nl/show/peter-pannekoek-krijgt-volop-bijval-na-uithaal-rond-staatsontvoeringen-naar-rutte~a49a8c9d/

1. Although youth care is intended for "protection", "care" and "help", it has caused a lot of human suffering in the Netherlands for decades, and offers little to no protection, care and help. Because of the sheer size of this public-private multibillion-dollar industry, a humanitarian disaster of unprecedented proportions has arisen. The vast majority of children in youth care are victims of unlawful out-of-home placements, "State kidnappings"[2], and therefore victims of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS/UHP). Approximately 450,000-900,000 children are victims of unlawful state interference and therefore also of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS). Nevertheless, the youth care industry continues to grow unhindered. In fact, Dutch youth care is no longer part of the rule of law, but is organized crime, intertwined with the public administration (mafia). 2. Since there is a deliberate, widespread, systematic attack against the Dutch civilian population (men, women and children), these human rights violations qualify as crimes against humanity; there is no statute of limitation. These crimes have been committed in the name of the municipality since 2015. The College of Mayor & Aldermen forms the day-to-day management, civil servants are involved, and the municipal council is the highest body that has to check the legality.

Individual members of the municipal council are therefore personally responsible and liable. I therefore urgently request you to ensure that all members of the Municipal council, of the College of Mayor and Aldermen, and the public servants involved receive a copy of this email and attachments. 3. This document contains a formal analysis based on laws and treaties on the (non)legality and injustice of Dutch youth care (chapters 3 – 5). The results are shocking, as they show that the chain partners operate as a crime syndicate, and that public administration and the judiciary are mixed with organized crime. The analysis shows that (almost) every child protection measure taken since 2015 is null and void, unjustified, illegal (illegal) and/or unlawful. These formal findings are independent of any future findings (of review committees) in the context of the substantive review at individual dossier level. Although these exercises are useful, we can no longer wait for the results. 4. This document is not only intended for members of the municipal councils, the College of Mayor & Aldermen, municipal officials and the negotiators who are now active after the elections of 16 March 2022.

The advice is also intended for every lawyer, every board member and every manager of a GI, every faction of the Senate or House of Representatives of the States General, every Minister, every policy officer of the Ministry of Justice and Security, every youth protector of a GI who must meet professional standards, every council researcher of the Council for Child Protection, every professor and every lecturer of universities and colleges , every lawyer and every judge, every foster parent, every family home parent and every self-employed person, employee or organization in the youth care chain. 5. On paper, the Netherlands is a rule of law, but the implementation practice of youth care is not. All ideals about "going to 0 out-of-home placements" remain illusory as long as the mixing of organized crime with the public administration and the judiciary is not abolished: for the next four years, a doubling of the growth of youth care is again foreseeable. In the circumstances outlined, the municipalities may no longer rely on a court order. You are aware of this advice, which is a follow-up to previous documents – most recently my letter of 28 January 2022 – insofar as you, as a professional or director, did not already know, or should not have known, these legal provisions and treaty provisions. 6.

Therefore, do not put your feelings and your conscience aside any longer, but do what is necessary: do justice to the victims and prevent new victims. The municipalities hold the key to stop this inhumane and barbaric commercial practice. The first concrete step is to end the funding and ensure that the children can return home. Children who have been placed under State supervision without a legal basis, illegally or unlawfully, should also be discharged from it. By means of adapted policies, municipalities can – and must – prevent new human rights violations. 7. If you have any questions, or want concrete help for your municipality or organization, I am of course available.

[2] https://www.ad.nl/show/peter-pannekoek-krijgt-volop-bijval-na-uithaal-rond-staatsontvoeringen-naar-rutte~a49a8c9d/

Kind regards/met vriendelijke groet,

Onderwerp: Consultatie EU Commissie over de rule of law Urgentie: Hoog Aan: Raadsgriffies van de Nederlandse Gemeenten Cc: Vereniging Nederlandse Gemeenten

“The destiny of human rights is in the hands of all our citizens in all our communities.” ~Eleanor Roosevelt

Amstelveen, 28 januari 2022

Geachte raadsgriffier, 1.

Hierbij zend ik u mijn bijdrage van 21 januari 2022 in het kader van het jaarlijkse consultatieproces dat de Europese Commissie sinds 2020 houdt om de kwaliteit van de rechtsorde van de EUlidstaten in kaart te brengen. Graag wil ik u verzoeken deze stukken ter kennisneming toe te voegen aan de stukken voor de (eerst)volgende raadsvergadering via ibabs.

2.

In mijn bijdrage ga ik in op de crisis in de Nederlandse rechtsstaat (zie ook Rapport Venetië Commissie d.d. 18 oktober 2021). Deze kan (grotendeels) worden verklaard door structurele weeffouten op systeemniveau en door de bestuurscultuur, maar laat zich juist voelen op

gemeentelijk niveau, in individuele dossiers in de uitvoeringspraktijk van die systemen. Dit is m.i. vooral zichtbaar in de jeugdzorg. 3.

Deze brief zend ik u dan ook mede in het belang van de meer dan 1.500 gedwongen afgestane/geadopteerde kinderen sinds 1956, meer dan 42.000 uit huis geplaatste kinderen (95.000 volgens de regering als wij de ‘drang’ trajecten in het zogenaamde ‘vrijwillig’ kader meerekenen) en 450.000 kinderen onder Staatstoezicht (mogelijk 900.000 indien ook hier kinderen via het ‘vrijwillige’ kader zijn geplaatst), 3.000 kinderen die al jaren in gesloten inrichtingen verblijven (jeugdgevangenissen), veelal zonder dat zij enig strafbaar feit hebben gepleegd, 2.500 verdwenen asielkinderen, 70.000 kinderen die slachtoffer zijn geworden van het Kinderopvangtoeslagschandaal, slachtoffers van satanisch ritueel misbruik en/of andere slachtoffers, hun ouders en verdere familie en dierbaren.

4.

Als bijlage bij de brief aan Europa treft u aan mijn brief van 14 januari 2022 aan de Verenigde Naties. In Geneve, Zwitersland, wordt op dit moment de vergadering gehouden van de CRC van de Verenigde Naties - Convention on the Rights of the Child, 89th Session (17 Jan 2022 - 11 Feb 2022), over Kroatië, Cuba, Cyprus, Djibouti, Griekenland, Kiribati, Madagascar, Nederland en Somalië. Meerdere (verdraaide) NGO’s en overheidsinstanties hebben de VN desgevraagd van informatie voorzien over de situatie van kinderrechten. Alleen al de Nederlandse jeugdzorg telde 109 organisaties en stakeholders als ondertekenaars (Kinderrechtencollectief). Geen van hen heeft de (aard en de omvang van de) misstanden en mensenrechtenschendingen binnen de Nederlandse jeugdzorg transparant gemaakt.

5.

Ik stel het op prijs indien: a. u de goede ontvangst van deze brief met bijlagen wilt bevestigen; b. u mij wilt informeren over de verdere behandeling in de gemeente; c. ik individuele of collectieve reacties mag ontvangen vanuit het college van B&W en/of de gemeenteraad en/of de fracties;

6.

Omwille van de transparantie vermeld ik dat ik kandidaat gemeenteraadslid ben voor de ChristenUnie Amstelveen op plaats 3 van de lijst. Net als Amstelveen, zal ook uw gemeente aan de laatste vergaderronde voor de verkiezingen bezig zijn, en eisen de lokale verkiezingscampagnes veel aandacht op. Daardoor zullen deze stukken mogelijk onvoldoende aandacht krijgen. Daarom wijs ik in mijn brief op het belang van deze stukken en onderbouw ik dit (misdaden tegen de menselijkheid).

7.

Ik verheug mij erop om in de nabije toekomst vanuit de nieuwe rol, samen met gemeenteraadsleden uit het hele land, te werken aan herstel van het vertrouwen in het openbaar bestuur, herstel van de democratische rechtsstaat, bescherming van de menselijke waardigheid en mensenrechten. Wij zijn het aan onze kinderen en kleinkinderen verplicht de misstanden en het ongekende onrecht zonder verder uitstel te beëindigen.

8.

Mochten er nog vragen zijn of u wenst een verdere toelichting, dan ben ik daartoe bereid. Uiteraard heb ik er geen bezwaar tegen indien u mijn gegevens verder deelt of deze brief met bijlagen verder wilt verspreiden. Integendeel.

9.

Voor meer informatie verwijs ik u naar de bijgesloten stukken. Graag van u vernemend.

Kind regards/met vriendelijke groet, Henriette Nakad-Weststrate

NAKAD LAW YOUR PARTNER IN JUSTICE

Please subscribe to our newsletter by clicking here! Schrijft u zich hier in voor de nieuwsbrief!

Dit e-mailbericht is gecontroleerd op virussen met Avast antivirussoftware. www.avast.com

Preface 1. Although youth care is intended for "protection", "care" and "help", it has caused a lot of human suffering in the Netherlands for decades, and offers little to no protection, care and help. Because of the sheer size of this public-private multibillion-dollar industry, a humanitarian disaster of unprecedented proportions has arisen. The vast majority of children in youth care are victims of unlawful out-of-home placements, "State kidnappings"1, and therefore victims of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS/UHP). Approximately 450,000-900,000 children are victims of unlawful state interference and therefore also of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS). Nevertheless, the youth care industry continues to grow unhindered. In fact, Dutch youth care is no longer part of the rule of law, but is organized crime, intertwined with the public administration (mafia). 2. Since there is a deliberate, widespread, systematic attack against the Dutch civilian population (men, women and children), these human rights violations qualify as crimes against humanity; there is no statute of limitation. These crimes have been committed in the name of the municipality since 2015. The College of Mayor & Aldermen forms the day-to-day management, civil servants are involved, and the municipal council is the highest body that has to check the legality.

Individual members of the municipal council are therefore personally responsible and liable. 3. This document contains a formal analysis based on laws and treaties on the (non)legality and injustice of Dutch youth care (chapters 3 – 5). The results are shocking, as they show that the chain partners operate as a crime syndicate, and that public administration and the judiciary are mixed with organized crime. The analysis shows that (almost) every child protection measure taken since 2015 is null and void, unjustified, illegal (illegal) and/or unlawful. These formal findings are independent of any future findings (of review committees) in the context of the substantive review at individual dossier level. Although these exercises are useful, we can no longer wait for the results. 4. This document is not only intended for members of the municipal councils, the College of Mayor & Aldermen, municipal officials and the negotiators who are now active after the elections of 16 March 2022.

The advice is also intended for every lawyer, every board member and every manager of a GI, every faction of the Senate or House of Representatives of the States General, every Minister, every policy officer of the Ministry of Justice and Security, every youth protector of a GI who must meet professional standards, every council researcher of the Council for Child Protection, every professor and every lecturer of universities and colleges , every lawyer and every judge, every foster parent, every family home parent and every self-employed person, employee or organization in the youth care chain. 5. On paper, the Netherlands is a rule of law, but the implementation practice of youth care is not. All ideals about "going to 0 out-of-home placements" remain illusory as long as the mixing of organized crime with the public administration and the judiciary is not abolished: for the next four years, a doubling of the growth of youth care is again foreseeable. In the circumstances outlined, the municipalities may no longer rely on a court order. You are aware of this advice, which is a follow-up to previous documents – most recently my letter of 28 January 2022 – insofar as you, as a professional or director, did not already know, or should not have known, these legal provisions and treaty provisions. 6.

Therefore, do not put your feelings and your conscience aside any longer, but do what is necessary: do justice to the victims and prevent new victims. The municipalities hold the key to stop this inhumane and barbaric commercial practice. The first concrete step is to end the funding and ensure that the children can return home. Children who have been placed under State supervision without a legal basis, illegally or unlawfully, should also be discharged from it. By means of adapted policies, municipalities can – and must – prevent new human rights violations. 7. If you have any questions, or want concrete help for your municipality or organization, I am of course available.

1

https://www.ad.nl/show/peter-pannekoek-krijgt-volop-bijval-na-uithaal-rond-staatsontvoeringen-naar-rutte~a49a8c9d/

1

Contents Preface ............................................................................................................................................................ 1 Chapter 1: State kidnappings ....................................................................................................................... 3 1.1 Human trafficking................................................................................................................................... 3 1.2 A humanitarian disaster ......................................................................................................................... 4 1.3 Correction of past mistakes ................................................................................................................... 5 1.4 Preventing new human rights violations ................................................................................................ 6 Chapter 2: The categories of Youth Care according to NJI ....................................................................... 7 2.1 What is youth care according to NJI ...................................................................................................... 7 2.2 Terminologie ..........................................................................................................................................

7 Chapter 3: Voluntary or forced help ............................................................................................................ 9 3.1 Voluntary help is the main rule .............................................................................................................. 9 3.2 Forced help is very rare ....................................................................................................................... 10 3.3 Consequences of the mixture in terms of legal protection .................................................................. 10 Chapter 4: integrity problems..................................................................................................................... 11 4.1 Conflicts of interests and network corruption....................................................................................... 11 4.2 Perverse financial incentives ............................................................................................................... 11 4.3 A harmful system ................................................................................................................................. 12 4.4 Governance culture: state terror ..........................................................................................................

12 4.5 Violation of human dignity (Article 1 EU Charter) ................................................................................ 13 Chapter 5: nullity and nullification ............................................................................................................. 15 5.1 Nullity (violation of the principle of legality) ......................................................................................... 15 5.2 Nullity (conflicts with mandatory articles of law or treaties) ................................................................. 15 5.3 Nullification (defects of free will) ......................................................................................................... 17 5.4 Legally valid grounds for child eviction ................................................................................................ 18 5.5 Illegal guidelines for returning the children home ................................................................................ 18 5.6 The execution of court orders .............................................................................................................. 19

2

Chapter 1: State kidnappings 1.1 Human trafficking 8. According to the United Nations, human trafficking is the recruitment, transport, transfer, housing or reception of people through violence, fraud or deceit, with the aim of exploiting them for profit. Men, women and children of all ages and backgrounds can fall victim to this crime, which occurs in every region of the world.2 9. In the Netherlands, child trafficking has occurred for more than 80 years, organized and financed by the Dutch State. This is done under the headings "Youth care", "Youth protection", "Youth assistance" etc. in a system of public-private partnership. With this trade one mainly earns money as the children are more damaged or more problems can be detected, manufactured or made up. 3 One earns little or no money, at least less, if the well-being of children is promoted and any actual problems or requests for help are solved quickly and appropriately. This approach is the basis of a multibillion-dollar industry at taxpayers' expense. 10. Youth care is a world in which children are taken away from their parents on the basis of faulty files and taken to an unknown location, with strangers, after which contact with their loved ones is forbidden or only sporadically allowed, often under the guise of 'confusing' and 'getting used to'.

These traumatizing experiences by definition cause psychological damage to children and parents. In addition, children are often abused and abused and appropriate help is not forthcoming. Many children are thus parked and detained for financial gain, on the basis of no more than false reports, unsubstantiated concerns, misdiagnoses, guesswork, the problematization and medicalization of the children by those who have a financial interest in it, and who also do not shy away from further (false) accusations of and unfounded concerns about the parents.4 11. Through repression and psychological torture, children and parents are forced into obedience, docility and silence and a culture of fear arises (Rutte Doctrine). Expressions of despair and sadness are punished by (further) restraining orders, the loss of parental authority (via the juvenile court), fines and imprisonment (via the criminal court, for example for insult) or the threat of such punitive measures. Because of the harassment, insults, humiliations, intimidation, threats and retaliation, etc. in the daily dealings with youth care, there is a lot of psychological suffering, sometimes with suicide, brain hemorrhages, heart attacks and cancer etc. as a result.5 12.

Youth care is also a world in which the perpetrators present themselves as interlocutors and confidants, who (compellingly) invite the victims to share their feelings with them. But they also force them to undergo psychological and medical acts and examinations by third parties, with at most the aim that they learn to 'accept' the unlawful situation as quickly as possible. In addition, there is an unwritten rule that the information – selectively, whether or not in distorted form – may be used by the certified institutions against them in further file formation and court cases. This also applies to the refusal to cooperate. 6 13. It is a world in which one's own mistakes and wrongful actions are not corrected, and the passage of time offers further guarantees to cash in on the children. The passage of time leads to further strengthening of one's own legal position and the (property) rights to the exploited children (modern slavery). A world where private equity funds, convicted sex offenders and fraudulent healthcare providers have made their appearance, to whom no obstacles are put in the way. A world that attracts people with personality disorders such as narcissism, psychopathy and sociopathy that does not prevent a climb on the career ladder. On the contrary.

A world in which whistleblowers are mercilessly dealt with and hunted down, even beyond national borders, just as parents who try to flee the Netherlands to protect their children are tackled and hunted down.

2

https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/human-trafficking/human-trafficking.html In the case of multiple problems, the term "complex problems" is usually used. 4 There are more patterns visible in the handling of files that indicate harmful psychological manipulation of children and parents that are also used in religious sects, for example, for the description of this, see https://sterzoeker.blogspot.com/2012/03/leervan-de-sektes.html. On the other hand, information is publicly available about the recognition and treatment of actual psychological/psychiatric problems, such as https://www.studeersnel.nl/nl/document/rijksuniversiteit-groningen/inleidingpsychiatrie-voor-juristen/inleiding-psychiatrie-voor-juristen-samenvatting/12136303 5 https://www.greelane.com/nl/geesteswetenschappen/problemen/us-constitution-22th-amendment-text-105391/; https://www.managementimpact.nl/art kel/machtsmisbru k-door-managers-een-bedreiging-voor-menswaardige-organisaties/; https://overheid.fnv-magazine.nl/012021/rutte-doctrine/; 6 https://recovery-freechoice.com/kenmerken-sekte/ 3

3|

1.2 A humanitarian disaster 14. Due to the enormous size of commercial youth aid, there is a humanitarian disaster. The vast majority of children in youth care are victims of unlawful out-of-home placements, "State abductions," and therefore victims of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS/UHP). There are 450,000-900,000 children who are victims of unlawful state interference and therefore also of human trafficking/exploitation/modern slavery (OTS). Despite the abuses, human rights violations and human suffering, the youth care industry continues to grow (fast). 15. This document contains a formal analysis based on laws and treaties on the (in)legality of Dutch youth care (chapters 3 – 5). The results are shocking. The analysis shows that (almost) every child protection measure taken since 2015 is null and void, unjustified, illegal (illegal) and/or unlawful. This is usually due to the fact that: (1) there is no legal basis for coercive measures, or (2) there is nullity due to violation of the principle of legality, violation of mandatory legal provisions, violation of treaty provisions, violations of principles of the rule of law. The administrative culture has characteristics of narcissism and sometimes sadism, which is contrary to the principles of good governance.

This administrative culture is partly explained by the (integrity) problems at system level, and in turn leads to (further) violation of human dignity; violation of Article 1 of the EU Charter, the most important treaty provision in the EU. These conclusions take priority over any review committees for the substantive assessment at individual file level. 16. Because there is a deliberate, widespread, systematic attack directed against the Dutch civilian population (men, women and children), the offences qualify as crimes against humanity. These are not timebarred. These crimes have been committed in the name of the municipality since 2015. The College of B&W forms the day-to-day management, civil servants are involved, and the municipal council is the highest body that has to check the legality. Individual members of the municipal council are therefore responsible and liable for this. 17. In fact, Dutch youth care is no longer part of the rule of law, but is organized crime, intertwined with the public administration (mafia). The proposal of the new Minister for Legal Protection Franc Weerwind for 420 children, namely a (costly, time-consuming, casuistic) material review at file level, and the judiciary that indicates in advance that some of the children will not be allowed to return home, makes this visible.

Although this material review will, in the long term, almost always have to lead to the conclusion of illegality (most files lack valid and reliable evidence, are not about concrete, serious development threats, are unsound due to forgery, false statements, unfounded concerns, false accusations, misdiagnoses, unilateral, selective file construction, etc.), these material problems at file level are not dealt with in this document. We can no longer do that, because the out-of-home placements are already null and void or unlawful on the basis of formal, systemic problems. 18. Is out-of-home placement of children due to perverse financial incentives in youth care, human trafficking? The answer was already given in 2012: "If the municipalities are also wise enough to set up the new financing system in such a way that actual results are judged instead of activities and lead times, then the perverse effect that by focusing on youth care trajectories and maximum lead times the goal (letting children develop safely) will also come to an end."7 19. It is not only a matter of reason to stop human rights violations, but also a matter of the rule of law, of mandatory legal and treaty provisions, and of integrity and humanity.

A small, civilized country like the Netherlands, when it brings youth care back within the limits of the rule of law, should place not more than a total of 420 children out of their homes, and at most 5,000 under State supervision. 20. In the current situation, municipalities are no longer allowed to rely on a court order. They hold the key to stop this inhumane and barbaric commercial practice. The first concrete step is to end the funding and ensure that the children can return home. Children who have been placed under State supervision without a legal basis, illegally or unlawfully, should also be discharged from it. In their policy, municipalities can – and must – prevent new human rights violations, for which they themselves are (partly) held responsible. 21. The legal and treaty provisions are not complicated, but are in line with the common sense and sense of justice with which every human being is naturally equipped. This document is not only intended for everyone who plays a role in the youth care chain. Ministers, MPs, administrators, policymakers, lawyers, lawyers and judges are expected to know the laws and treaties. 7

Domestic governance, 02 April 2012: The end of perverse incentives. Column by Erik Gerritsen about the financing of youth care. Link: https://www.binnenlandsbestuur.nl/sociaal/het-einde-van-de-perverse-prikkels-column-van-erik-gerritsen-over-definanciering-van-de

4|

1.3 Correction of past mistakes 22. Municipalities can – and must – do the following to restore the rule of law: a. Municipalities cease the financing of void and unlawful out-of-home placements and supervision. b. Municipalities have the right and duty to reclaim funding for void child protection measures in recent years. They are obliged under Article 162 of the Code of Civil Procedure to report criminal offences. c. Children unlawfully removed from their homes must return home immediately, without further investigation, court order or relocation process, because they are staying with strangers without a legal basis. Unlawful state interference (surveillance) must be stopped immediately, including early warning and risk lists in the way it is currently set up. The "protection" is null and void, unlawful and harmful. d. Parents and children are generously financially compensated for the damage and suffering caused. 23. Under void and unlawful removals and supervision he following examples are included, as a minimum (see Chapters 3 to 5). a.

A ('voluntary') agreement of supervision and/or joint management by the Certified Institution (OTS) and/or the eviction (UHP) via contract law, i.e. without a court order, whereby the parents can no longer decide independently and autonomously when the assistance ends, is null and void, (1) due to violation of mandatory legal provisions and (2) due to violation of international treaty provisions, as a result of which they are contrary to morality or public order by their content or purport.

b.

The court order in which an out-of-home placement has been pronounced must state which less harmful alternatives have been tried first (Article 8 ECHR). Court orders in which out-of-home placement has been pronounced, without the network being mapped, living relatives, friends, neighbors, church, mosque, shul, etc. and others, and the court has not determined that they refuse to provide assistance to the child, and has not given priority to it, are unlawful. Less harmful alternatives that should be given priority to shall be at least: (i) parents can follow a parenting course; (ii) parents can follow an autism course or other relevant course and possibly ambulatory help and / or day care depending on the wishes of the parents; (iii) parent(s) and child will (temporarily) move in with family or others from the network; (iv) family or others from the network come in temporarily for support; (v) there will be informal care or outpatient care at home one or more days a week, or only during the 'rush hours' (preparing children for school, dinner time, etc.); (vi) in the event of financial problems, the family is protected and helped by its own family and the network, possibly with the help of the municipality, so that the stress that this causes also decreases; (vii) the municipality ensures that there is sufficient varied housing supply, so that the family can possibly live in a

residential group, where the child is protected and parents offer each other support and conviviality; (viii) in the case of domestic violence, the child is not taken out of the home, but the perpetrator of violence must always leave the house (with family or friends or other housing, which is the responsibility of the perpetrator), and less harmful forms of support and aftercare are organized.

c.

A child eviction without the decision having been served in advance pursuant to Article 430 paragraph 3 Dutch Code of Civil Proceedings is null and void.

d.

Court orders in which an extension of an eviction has been pronounced on the basis of a perspective decision are null and void, (1) because of a violation of mandatory legal provisions and (2) because of violation of international treaty provisions. The judges should have disapplied these directives ex officio under Article 94 of the Dutch Constitution.

e.

A child protection measure without a prior plan, as a result of which it is not certain in court that the requested measure will work, and if so, within what (reasonable) period, or the positive effect of which cannot be guaranteed, or that the measure in itself causes harm and on balance does not bring any improvement for the child or that this can be doubted. The legal provision that a plan can be made within six weeks is null and void by operation of law and should have been disapplied by judges under Article 94 of the Constitution. Supervision only because of the desire to monitor the

5|

family and/or the concern that problems might arise in the future is contrary to mandatory legal provisions and international treaties. Extensions of measures based on a perspective decision that is (partly) based on illegal directives are also null and void. Court orders contrary to this are null and void and must be disapplied. These are forms of modern slavery and exploitation of children. f.

Spying on parents and families in the name of prevention and early detection, the creation of blacklists on the basis of risk lists, are contrary to mandatory legal provisions and violation of international treaty provisions, but also constitute a violation of the rule of law itself. Preventive supervision of young, pregnant girls and the taking of their baby at delivery or shortly thereafter is also prohibited and null and void on the same grounds. This is contrary to mandatory legal provisions, protective treaty provisions and contrary to the principles of the rule of law.

g.

The entire system of youth care, in which no Chinese Walls have been implemented between voluntary aid and coercive measures, is illegitimate, because this system by definition leads to human rights violations and lawlessness , and makes the protection of family life illusory. This is the result of (foreseeable) integrity problems, such as conflicts of interest, network corruption, perverse financial incentives, a governance culture of lawlessness and state terror, and ultimately personal interests in (continuing to) commit criminal offences, and afterwards denying, nuanced, and cover-up the crimes. It is a state within a state.

1.4 Preventing new human rights violations 24. The following steps must be taken – without further delay – to prevent new abuses and human rights violations: a. The municipality no longer allows new void and unlawful forms of state supervision and out-ofhome placements. b. The municipality no longer allows placement in closed accommodations. c. The municipality combats the integrity problems of the current system: they dismantle spy services and secret police services, and build Chinese Walls to ensure the separation between voluntary help and forced protection; d. The municipality ceases the future financing of void and unlawful child protection measures, so that these exceptions remain. e. Those responsible for serious abuses and human rights violations in the past are not appointed alderman for youth care, and the municipality breaks ties with institutions that were responsible for the violations. f. The municipality promotes help to families under its own control through its own general practitioner, and ensures that the administration of the PCIs is so simple that each family can do this with help from its own network and, if necessary, from the municipality. Once PCIs have been issued, they will not be reclaimed. Errors are at the expense and risk of the municipality; the officials involved and their managers at SVB and the municipalities are responsible.

6|

Chapter 2: The categories of Youth Care according to NJI 2.1 What is youth care according to NJI 25. In July 2021, an overview of the Netherlands Youth Institute, the NJI, was published: "Help! What is the difference between youth care and youth care?" 8 According to the NJI, the concept of youth care is an overarching concept, and since the introduction of the Youth Act 2015, it is understood to mean the following: a. youth help: ➢ Help with psychological problems, intellectual disability, parenting problems. ➢ Youth help without residence: o Neighbourhood or neighbourhood team o Outpatient on-site assistance provider o Day care on location provider o Help in network (at home, at school) ➢ Youth help with residence: o Foster family o Family-oriented care (guest houses or care farms) o Closed placement in institution o Other youth assistance with residence Carried out by youth care providers. b. youth protection: ➢ State Supervision ➢ Guardianship Carried out by certified institutions. c. juvenile probation ➢ Supervision and guidance forced ➢ Supervision and guidance voluntary ➢ Individual trajectory guidance Carried out by certified institutions. 26. Before going into the violation of laws and treaties in chapters 3 to 5, which are made visible by this overview, first in this chapter 2 is briefly discussed the terminology that immediately leads to a lot of confusion.

2.2 Terminologie 27. In general, the terminology of the NJI is not sufficiently in line with the Youth Act and the Dutch Civil Code.9 Examples: •

The Youth Act defines "youth help" as follows: 1. support of, and help and care, other than prevention, to young people and their parents in reducing, stabilizing, treating and eliminating or dealing with the consequences of psychological problems and disorders, psychosocial problems, behavioral problems or an intellectual disability of the youth, parenting problems or adoption-related problems; 2. promoting the participation in society and the independent functioning of young people with a somatic, mental, physical or sensory disability, a chronic psychological problem or a psychosocial problem and who have not yet reached the age of eighteen, and 3. supporting or taking over activities in the field of personal care aimed at eliminating a lack of selfreliance in young people with a mental, physical or sensory disability or a somatic or psychiatric disorder or disability, who have not yet reached the age of eighteen.

•

"Youth protection" is not a legal term; the Youth Act defines the term "child protection measures." This means: 1. voogdij en voorlopige voogdij op grond van Boek 1 van het Burgerlijk Wetboek, en 2. ondertoezichtstelling, bedoeld in artikel 255, eerste lid, van Boek 1 van het Burgerlijk Wetboek en voorlopige ondertoezichtstelling, bedoeld in artikel 257, eerste lid, van Boek 1 van het Burgerlijk Wetboek. (Het begrip jeugdbeschermingsmaatregelen komt één maal voor in artikel 8.2.1 lid 5 Jeugdwet.)

•

'Juvenile probation' refers to:

8

https://www.nji.nl/sites/default/files/2021-07/Wat-is-het-verschil-tussen-jeugdzorg-en-jeugdhulp-handout.pdf In addition, the terminology of the Youth Act does not correspond to the Dutch Civil Code (for example, the definition of "parents"). This adds to the confusion, but is beyond the scope of this commentary. 9

7|

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

probation activities, referred to in Article 77hh, first paragraph, of the Criminal Code, accompaniment referred to in article 77hh, second paragraph, of that code and supervising and supervising juveniles who participate in a education and training program as referred to in Article 3 of the Principles Act on Juvenile Justice Institutions, giving the instructions referred to in Article 12, fifth paragraph, of that Law, or the other tasks assigned to the certified bodies by or pursuant to the law.

•

"Youth care with residence" is not a legal term, but this is a UHP (out of home placement). This is a form of child protection and not of help, and is a last resort.

•

"Closed youth assistance" is: the UHP with an admission, stay and youth assistance in a closed accommodation (an architectural facility or part of an architectural facility with the associated site, where closed youth assistance is provided). A closed accommodation is actually a juvenile detention centre, where children (sometimes for years), without criminal conviction, are deprived of their liberty. In the absence of protection and control, a regime of terror prevails in many accommodations. It is a form of long-term deprivation of liberty of minors that is at odds with international conventions, including for violation of human dignity. Incidentally, articles 6.1.2-6.1.4 Youth Act are clearly in conflict with legal and treaty provisions in parts, for example that a minor should be locked up on no more than suspicions (guesswork). This form of "aid" is so harmful ("inhumane and barbaric") and ineffective that many believe it should be completely dismantled.

•

Finally, the word "youth care" does not appear in the Youth Act 2015. This is not only (i) an overarching concept, as the NJI rightly points out, but (ii) it is also the collective name for the entire branch/youth care chain including the commercial care providers and even of foster parents and family home owners, and (iii) it is also used as an indication of one or more separate organizations from the industry, the chain partners.

8|

Chapter 3: Voluntary or forced help 28. The first major difficulty in the NJI overview is the mixing of (i) voluntary aid and (ii) forced help. Especially for the legal position of parents and child, the separation of these two forms of assistance is of great importance. The NJI knows that, or at least it should know that, just as lawyers and judges know this, or at least should know.

3.1 Voluntary help is the main rule 29. Article 1:247 of the Dutch Civil Code (parental authority) not only gives parents the right, but also imposes on them the duty, each own child (himself! ) to educate and care for. Pursuant to Article 1:247 of the Dutch Civil Code (parental authority, 'family life'), the autonomy of the parents is leading. This makes voluntary help the main rule. "The law assumes – and this is also the social view – that every parent is in principle suitable for parenthood and has or can have custody of his or her children. There are – from a pedagogical point of view – very good parents, there are reasonable parents and there are moderate parents. All of them are loving parents and are given custody and are charged with the care and upbringing of their children and often – also with the moderate parents – without any involvement of youth protection. The Council is on the line that it must be investigated – in short – whether father can do it. For father, however, what applies to all parents in the Netherlands applies: he does not have to take an exam to prove that he is a good parent. It is the other way around: only if it turns out that the father cannot cope with parenthood, there is reason not to entrust the father with custody and care in deviation from the principle."

Source: judgment of the Noord-Holland District Court of 4 March 2020, Case number C/15/290923 / FA RK 19-3922, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2020:2091 30. Parental authority includes autonomy (the "general policy) and also the self-direction (concrete decisions), while the child in principle lives at home, or after divorce alternately with the parents (regular family life, "family life"). The family is part of the social network (grandfathers and grandmothers and other family, friends, neighbors, acquaintances, neighborhood children, classmates, etc.). Parents are free to seek and/or allow external advice, interference or help where necessary. They can purchase these externally, directly or through their own general practitioner pursuant to Article 2.6 paragraph 1 under e Youth Act, so without interference from youth care. This referral gives access to youth care. There are two situations when parents call on the municipality for funding: Situation 1. The referral concerns contracted youth care. This is paid directly by the municipality to the youth care provider. Situation 2. The referral concerns non-contracted youth care. In that case, parents can apply for a PGB. The municipality may check whether the PGB conditions are met, but may not check the need for access to youth care if the general practitioner has already determined this.

If the PGB conditions are met, the municipality issues the PGB. If the conditions are not met, the municipality offers a contracted alternative. 31. The autonomy of parents also implies a high degree of (policy) freedom. For example, parents can look at the situation for a while ('do not pull grass to make it grow faster'). In case of concerns about the children, it is common for parents to consult with people from their own social network. 32. Furthermore, parents and children derive protection from the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and other treaties. a. On the basis of Article 3 paragraph 2 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Dutch State must take into account the rights and obligations of parents, and the State must respect the responsibilities, rights and obligations of the parents on the basis of Article 5 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. Children and parents are also protected from interference with family life by other European and international treaties.10 b. Article 43 of the Statute for the Kingdom of the Netherlands provides: '(1) Each of the countries shall ensure the realisation of fundamental human rights and freedoms, legal certainty and the soundness of governance. (2) The safeguarding of those rights, freedoms, legal certainty and sound administration is a matter for the Kingdom.' c.

Article 93 of the Constitution states: 'Provisions of treaties and of decisions of organisations governed by international law which, by their content, may bind everyone, shall have binding effect after they have been published.'

10

Think of: Article 8 ECHR, Articles 1 and 7 of the European Charter, the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child , the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 3 of the Istanbul Convention and Article 7 of the Rome Statute, Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, etc.

9|

d.

Article 94 of the Constitution states: 'Legal provisions in force within the Kingdom shall not apply if such application is not compatible with provisions of treaties and decisions of international organisations which are binding on everyone.'

3.2 Forced help is very rare 33. In the case of child protection measures, parental authority is completely or partially eroded or taken away by order of the State; 11 these measures may only be imposed where it has been established on the basis of valid and reliable evidence that there is a concrete, serious threat of development on the part of the child, while the parents are in the way of necessary care. In that case, the autonomy, but usually also the self-direction, is always taken away in whole or in part from the parents (OTS). At OTS/UHP, the child is even taken away and made available to third parties, who take over the daily upbringing and care in full. In all these cases, there is interference in family life. Then the children become the "children of the State". 34. The Netherlands has a remarkably high number of child protection measures. This is a first indication that these instruments are being used too quickly. As has been said, children and parents should enjoy protection against interference with family life by European and international treaties. That protection goes very far. So much so that, on the basis of Article 94 of the Constitution, legal provisions in force within the Kingdom do not apply if this application is not compatible with it. 12 35.

In doing so, the government has to take into account the effectiveness of the measures, but also the requirements of proportionality and subsidiarity and the prohibition of détournement de pouvoir and other principles of good administration, from which citizens also derive protection, are not without consequences. This means that priority must always be given to the upbringing and care of the parents, with the support of their own social network and within it in particular the family.

3.3 Consequences of the mixture in terms of legal protection 36. The consequence of mixing voluntary aid with forced help is an impairment of legal protection. In Dutch performance practice, the protection of parental authority and the protection of the rights of the child are completely lacking, as the NJI overview shows. Practice has many examples. Example 1. One or more employees of the youth care chain are deployed by the municipality in the handling of requests for a PGB for voluntary youth care, instead of referring parents to their general practitioner. They are going to form an opinion about the necessity of the aid. Example 2. These employees take the opportunity to do a (disguised) investigation into the family, and ask the parents questions. In doing so, they actively look for problems other than the original request for help, for example attachment disorders, family problems or other starting points to build a file for child protection measures (détournement de pouvoir). Even though there are no concrete starting points, they still develop concerns. In the conversation, the parents are being told that there are many concerns, partly child own and partly family related, and that they have to sign a voluntary agreement with the GI, because otherwise OTS will be applied for through the court.

This is actually a common complaint: "I asked for help, but I received problems." Example 3. What the parents do not know is that the GI has often agreed with the municipality (on paper or as a 'gentlemen's agreement') that they will provide employees free of charge to the periodic “youth protection tables”, but that at least two children at a time will be placed under OTS, for which the municipality guarantees funding. It sounds like a win/win: the municipality ensures quality, and the GI secures a profitable time investment. However, this is one of the most direct forms of child trafficking within the system. However, these agreements should remain inapplicable because of the protection of family life. 37. Compliance with legal and treaty provisions must be ensured. The NJI knows this, or at least it should know this. This requires a complete separation between voluntary and forced help, and this must be reflected in the organization of the youth care system, and therefore in the overview of the NJI.

11

The first important goal of the Youth Act is: 1. Making use of the own strength of young people, parents and their social network. It is important that they remain in control of their lives. And that they look for solutions together with their own environment and professional care providers. https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/jeugdhulp/jeugdhulp-bijgemeenten#:~:text=Gemeenten%20zijn%20verantwoordelijk%20voor%20de,Dat%20staat%20in%20de%20Jeugdwet. 12 Think of: Article 8 ECHR, Articles 1 and 7 of the European Charter, the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child , the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 3 of the Istanbul Convention and Article 7 of the Rome Statute, Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, etc.

10 |

Chapter 4: integrity problems 38. The mixing of voluntary help and coercive measures not only leads to an erosion of the legal protection of parents and children, but also creates integrity problems.

4.1 Conflicts of interests and network corruption 39. In practice, especially from the part of youth care, the pretense is that families and youth care serve the same interest, namely the interest of the child. This is not the case. Families have different interests than youth care. On the one hand, the interest of parents and children is the protection of their family life and Article 1:247 of the Dutch Civil Code, and quick answers and solutions to their requests for help. On the other hand, the chain partners have their own interest in infringing on family life and bringing the children into their power. Both their "business model" and their raison d'être are based on damaged children or inadequate, unsuitable parents. The supply of new damaged children and/or the further damage to children already placed in their power (OTS or OTS/UHP) is necessary for the continuity of the chain partners, both official organizations and entrepreneurs: their annual budget or their turnover depends on this. 40. The interests of families and youth care are opposed to each other. (i) By mixing voluntary help and coercion, a youth care worker must serve multiple interests, which can exert such an influence on each other that the integrity of one and/or the other interest is compromised. In the case of opposite interests, there is by definition a conflict of interest.

(ii) At the organizational level, the parallel (financial) interests of the chain partners create the problem of network corruption. Network corruption is the phenomenon that people who know each other, at the local or national level, form an exclusive network that excludes others. The members are very loyal and supportive and do not allow criticism. In their cooperation – the chain partners are also informants of each other and provide each other with evidence, which is accepted by the judges as independent – they can work towards a result that is beneficial for everyone in the chain, to which the interests of the child and parents are subordinated. 41. Both phenomena, the conflict of interest and the network corruption, are foreseeable. The Trias Politica was thus known for 2015 by the laws and regulations of financial supervision, including the further regulations on controlled and ethical business operations and conduct supervision) that the legislative and executive powers themselves have made, and which the judiciary has often considered. These systemic errors explain why the abuses could have arisen, such as institutional forgery, inadequate file formation, resulting in unprecedented injustice and human suffering. 42.

The conflict of interest is further reinforced at organizational and personal level, because university professors are allowed to conduct government-sponsored research into youth care, because judges give courses to youth care institutions, through periodic formal and informal consultations, meetings, conferences and drinks between the chain partners, and the culture of punishments and rewards. This encourages a (tacit) code of honour, the "Omerta in the polder".

4.2 Perverse financial incentives 43. An additional problem is the perverse incentives. Perverse incentives arise because the youth care chain (public/private) is so powerful that it can fully control the demand for its own services. 44. The chain partners do this in practice by false accusations by parents, by stretching the grounds for outof-home placement, by unnecessarily problematizing and medicalizing children, by failing to investigate less harmful alternatives, and by committing forgery (inventing problems, constructing, exaggerating, aggravating, aggravating, cause, provoke incidents, and ignore favorable information for parents, reject it, keep it out of the file, etc.), by structurally siding with the violent, narcissistic and troubled and troublecausing parent in divorces and presenting this as a conflict between parents, and finally suppressing any form of criticism from parents (parents are threatened if they are on social media dare to express their dissatisfaction, complaints or despair, and youth care strikes back with retaliatory actions such as contact restrictions, prohibitions or taking parental authority). 45.

De tekst is automatisch uit het bestand gehaald en kan afwijken van het origineel (kolommen, tabellen en koppen lopen door elkaar). Het officiële stuk bij de gemeente is leidend. Bron: https://api1.ibabs.eu/publicdownload.aspx?site=BergenOpZoom&id=bf0b7074-8cea-401a-8aaa-362c9f7f0e5f